But if I was looking for a flat panel, I wouldn't even spend one minute researching LCD. Im serious. I just told my friend that yesterday who was looking for advice. And he said, "really", and I said, yup.
for a 42", you gotta be sittin real close for 1080p to even be beneficial for you. I mean, reeeaaall close.
Just a week or two ago, there was a Panny 720p plasma selling for $799. Cant remember if shipping was free. I highly doubt that 1080p will do anything for you.
and especially because you love standard def, plasma totally kills LCD in this regard. Actually, I think plasma kills LCD in a number of regards, but SD is right up there.
SD on a plasma looks like HD-lite. I first used to think... "oh, that's not a very good HD signal at all!".... and then realize, oh its not HT. Not bad for an SD signal on a modern flat panel, I would think...
SD on a LCD looks like barf. Ultra blurry, macroblocking, or whatever the heck is happening. It looks awful IMO.
Am looking to get a Flat-panel in the near future (seriously, this time....) and am looking for a little input.
First, here's some info which might help...
Budget: At or under $1600
Size: 40" - 42"
Use: Movie watching (have a substantial DVD collection, not looking to upgrade my DVD player for a while), with a little cable surfing now and then.
Existing: all standard def. stuff with regular component cables (if this even makes a difference)
The whole 720p/1020p issue doesn't really matter to me much as all my existing equipment (which pretty much consists of a JVC HX-D77 all-in-one) is standard def. and I'm not looking to upgrade anytime soon. However, I'm still on the fence regarding LCD vs. Plasma....wondering about the long-term reliability mainly and if the cost benefit is truly a trump card here.
I've done my homework here the panels I've looked at the closest are Samsung's PN42A450 (plasma) and LG's 42LG30 (LCD). Could I do better than either of those given my info?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic