External Hard Drive: Portable vs Non Portable

May 8, 2011 1:17PM PDT

Hey everyone,
I am planning to buy a new external harddrive for everyday use like movies, music,pictures etc. I will be connecting it to my xbox mostly to watch movies. Now i had Western Digital Elements 1TB and it only lasted for a year. There are two types that am confused between the portable ones (which are smaller in size) and regular big ones. If you guys could tell me if there is any other difference than the obvious size difference? I know portable cost just a bit more. But is there any speed difference. Also does big ones last longer than portables? Also which one you guys recommend? I was looking to buy for under $150. Size 500 GB - 1 TB.

Discussion is locked

Reply to: External Hard Drive: Portable vs Non Portable
PLEASE NOTE: Do not post advertisements, offensive materials, profanity, or personal attacks. Please remember to be considerate of other members. If you are new to the CNET Forums, please read our CNET Forums FAQ. All submitted content is subject to our Terms of Use.
Reporting: External Hard Drive: Portable vs Non Portable
This post has been flagged and will be reviewed by our staff. Thank you for helping us maintain CNET's great community.
Sorry, there was a problem flagging this post. Please try again now or at a later time.
If you believe this post is offensive or violates the CNET Forums' Usage policies, you can report it below (this will not automatically remove the post). Once reported, our moderators will be notified and the post will be reviewed.
- Collapse -
Depends where you want to use it
May 13, 2011 11:31PM PDT

The basic differences between Portable and non-portable drives are the form factor of the disks they use and their power source. As you have observed, portable drives are smaller and are usually powered directly off the USB port to which they are connected. Non-portable drives are bigger and are usually separately powered.

Portable drives are based on the 2.5" drive used in laptops and other (not surprisingly) portable computers. They tend to have a smaller capacity and usually but not always operate at a slower speed, e.g. 5400 rpm, rather than 7200.

Non-portable drives are based on the 3.5" drives normally used in desktop systems, tend to have larger capacities (up to 3 TB) and operate at the faster desktop speeds, typically 7200 rpm. But this extra weight and speed requires more power than can usually be supplied by a USB port and so they come with an external power source.

The origin of the disks gives a clue as to the difference in portability. Desktops are assumed not to move frequently, at least, not while powered on and so it was also assumed that the disks wouldn't suffer the accidental knocks and drops that would be associated with a portable device. The bigger platters and longer read/write arms do flex more and are not as shock resistant as smaller devices. So a 3.5" non-portable external drive should not be moved while powered on and dropping one is usually fatal.

With the advent of laptops, something more robust was required, that could withstand the shock of a laptop being picked up and typically rotated through 90 degrees to be carried and, unfortunately, knocked or dropped on occasion. While you can carry a powered on laptop around, it's always wisest to close the lid and put it in standby, so the disk(s) have stopped spinning. Enter the 2.5" drive, its smaller physical size makes it inherently less susceptible to shock and the manufacturers have gone to some lengths to enhance this capability. Basically, it is assumed that they will be frequently moved around.

I assume your Xbox is relatively static and so that would suggest a non-portable drive would suffice but where would you get the movies from? If you get them from your camcorder or PC, and that means you need to move the external drive frequently, you might want to consider a portable drive, though within your house, providing it isn't powered on when you move it, a non-portable drive should be OK. You don't say why your WD failed after only a year, that is unusual unless it's been (shall we say) not treated kindly. That might push you to a portable, assuming the Xbox USB ports have enough power to drive it.

One last comment - do remember that ALL disks eventually die - so do remember to keep a backup of the movies, etc., on your external drive. One copy is never enough.

Hope this helps.

- Collapse -
External Hard Drive: Portable vs Non Portable
May 13, 2011 11:40PM PDT

For the most part, the portable external hard drives are powered via a cable connection to the usb port of a computer. Also, almost all of this type are flash drives, while the "regular big ones" are standard hard drives(using lasers), in an enclosure with plug-in power supply.

- Collapse -
External Hard Drive: Portable vs Non Port
Aug 25, 2011 6:16PM PDT

Portable drives use 2.5" hard drives which are typically smaller in capacity and slower. Regular external hard drives (Non-Portable) use 3.5" hard drives which are larger in capacity and faster. 2.5" Portable hard drives are usually 5400 RPM and 3.5" hard drives are usually 7200 RPM but now a day's 2.5" drives also comes in 7200 RPM. Generally, a 2.5" portable drive comes without external power. For the 3.5" disk you'll need that adapter. Portable are more expensive, but it is convenient because you can take it anywhere with you. I have the Strontium SSD Matrix portable hard drive. It is easy to carry and also you need not to worry about protection because it comes with protection case.

CNET Forums

Forum Info