Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

equipment help creating hi quality dvds from tape and miniDV

Jun 13, 2005 8:54AM PDT

Question: I am involved in a huge project for a non-profit to copy hundreds of hi-8 tapes, VHS tapes, and mini-dvs to DVD for permanent (or as permanent as possible) archive and to have one copy to play. We are trying to get as high quality as possible for each medium. They do not need to be edited at this time, just copied. Because there are so many, a simpler solution would be ideal, but quality is the issue.

Currently we are using:
to record: a Panasonic DMR HS2 DVD recorder.
To play back mini DV: Panasonic PV-GS9 digital video camcorder.
To play back 8 mm tape: Sony Video Hi8 with flying eraser head, EV-C200.
To play back VHS: Toshiba M-66.

mini DV questions:
1)X Is there a difference in quality copying from mini DV to DVD depending on the quality of the playback camera, or is this irrelevant?

2)Is it better to play back mini dv from a non-camera deck because of so many tapes? If so, any recommendations?

3) Although we don't need to edit now, we will need to within the next year. Does it therefore make sense buy the equipment now and to copy to a computer and burn DVD's from the computer, or wait for new developments?

4) Is firewire the best, and is there any difference in cables?

other tape questions:

5) Do you know of any equipement better (ie, faster, simpler, higher quality) than what we are using?

Many, many thanks in advance for any help.

Cerulean

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Just from experience with the Avid and Final Cut people.
Jun 13, 2005 9:27AM PDT

1. Couldn't tell the difference. miniDV is digital so ... it's digital at that point.

2. The pros tend to use a deck. Cameras tend to wear out too fast.

3. This one is confusing. I was able to transfer, edit and make DVDs with a lowly p3-600 laptop. Surely you have at least this?

4. Yes and no.

5. Faster at what? You didn't tell what needed to be faster.

Bob

- Collapse -
my 2 cents
Jun 14, 2005 8:51AM PDT

1. Probably not. All it's doing is picking up and sending out bits. I would be more concerned about what, if any, conversion is being made to put it on DVD. Mini DVs can hold almost 3 times as much information as a DVD.
2. Yes.
3. Wait for the final equipment before starting. The software and hardware will probably be better.
4. Firewire is the highest speed option available at the consumer level.
5. No.

HTH