I think that they throw away the old one the aren't listened to or watched if you wanted to keep them all you should have back them up to a external hard drive. That way you wouldn't lose them at all. With all of the iTunes updates I think that iTunes dump the older ones.
I have used itunes to download BUZZ out loud for a few years, saving all episodes. Today I came home and discovered that, without changing anything about 2/3 of my episodes are gone! All of February except today. Part of January and I only have about 30 from 2008 and less from 2007! What happened? Itunes will only re-download This month! And I have to unsubscribe and re-subscribe to do that!!!
What happened?
Jonathan

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic