Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Detroit woes and similar

Mar 8, 2010 10:06PM PST

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
they can take other steps
Mar 8, 2010 11:12PM PST

Detroit has been decimated by union activity. Now the biggest one has left, UAW. The ones currently a problem are the city services unions. Outlaw the unions for any city paid job. Adjust payments according to what the city can afford. Any worker who can't accept that may leave, the city can hire others who are desperate for the job.

In areas that are going rural, leave 4-6 homes in an area, provide with local source of water, install septic tanks. In those areas part go to woodlands, others to meadow, other areas for local agriculture. Quit maintaining roads in nature areas, let them decay naturally, they can be removed later when funds allow. No need to dig up existing water and sewage lines, just disconnect from them, they will stay buried, out of the way. In areas where there are roads but nobody living there anymore and it set for return to nature, close off access to those roads to avoid it becoming used for criminal enterprises.

If all else fails, give free plane tickets to the poorest, sent to cities where employment is higher and they have access to some funds from Detroit for a few months to restart there.

- Collapse -
Detroit has been decimated by union activity.
Mar 9, 2010 4:39AM PST

So, not cheaper Japanese and other car imports then?

Mark

- Collapse -
I think James means ...
Mar 9, 2010 4:57AM PST

that salaries and benefits in the USA car industry were so high and costly (due to the power of the unions) that other countries could make cheaper cars with cheaper labor.

It's the same story, more or less, as with Chinese textiles, toys, electronics and other exports. For some reason, the average American union member (I don't know about the non-union members) doesn't like to work 12 hours a day for 1$ an hour or so.

Kees

- Collapse -
Squeeze of die
Mar 9, 2010 5:18AM PST

Don't be so quick to blame unions. I find that all too easy to do so. While, I agree its part of the problem, until you work in a dirty job of "any sort" do you understand the need for unions. Much of the industry that was "blue collar" of Detroit got send down South and later abroad. Sure, it was cheaper to do so, but what did you get, cheaper parts and questionable sources. This is not to blame foreign makers that got in and offered their wares like cars, nut&bolts, etc. that's a global economy. Its entirely a different thing when the co. moves offshore and sets up shop. It may not happen there and then, but sooner or later the buyers like you and me can't afford or be able to afford if not employed. You can be a CEO of a company, but if that co. goes overseas or gets shipped elsewhere, even you can be let go.

ZAs for Detroit reducing its size in order to support what's left is the result of short slightness and/or improper local govt. as well. Past city mayors and council have been jailed and basically looked out for themselves. maybe the action has to be done, but to see many a decent home become worthless and dozed just seems so much a a waste. As for city services, well you have to cut back and cutting back will be setting free those areas not supporting their wieght. Why not let them become townships again and let their own citizenry do the work required with available funds, if possible as another option. But, I thought the big city will do that as they lose that tax base, etc.. -----Willy Happy

- Collapse -
the end result was the same, but....
Mar 9, 2010 8:21AM PST

... a lot didn't go "overseas" but "north" to Canada. The Lumina for instance we had was a Canadian built car. I had to pull a fuse to disable it's daytime running lights at the time, got tired of US drivers flash lights at me in the daytime. Now daytime running lights are more common in US.

- Collapse -
Yes, true
Mar 9, 2010 12:19PM PST

All US car makers have plants in Canada and have for yrs. before any of this got bad. That's also common in Mexico. It started small then got larger and larger. It makes a heck of alot of sense to have plants at least close by(across border) than to be overseas. Further, what they ship in machinery usually is far better than what those countries had or step-up for them. Not always the case but usually is. Once its gone outside of the US for whatever reason it hardly ever comes back. Regardless, the exodus of labor to outside the US besides any car building is far too common. Even dang toothpicks are made overseas. I found out, the strike matches are too. Even a US plant can't even do that, then who do you blame(blame game) because I'm sure once you dig you find it wasn't labor at the heart of all these problems. -----Willy Shocked

- Collapse -
(NT) Bus tickets
Mar 9, 2010 8:44AM PST
- Collapse -
I thought of that, but...
Mar 9, 2010 9:01AM PST

...can't change mind and get off a plane a stop or two down the road and come back. Also by ending up at an airport, they'd have to seek out the bus station which is usually NOT located at the airport to get a ticket back if they changed their mind. The idea is make it difficult for them to take a vacation for a weekend and then return.

- Collapse -
If they can do this with landfills
Mar 8, 2010 11:20PM PST
- Collapse -
Detroit has been in decline for a long time...
Mar 8, 2010 11:27PM PST

Look who's running the place.

- Collapse -
In the 1940s it was an exciting
Mar 9, 2010 5:12AM PST

..... place to visit.

The river front was well developed for walking and enjoying the view, (and there was Canada on the other side!). The Vernor's Ginger Ale factory offered a selection of different flavors, and hot peanut vendors nearby. There was a frozen malted confection for "desert". Wink

And there were street cars!!! The area where they turned around was near the river.

I liked crossing over the Ambassador Bridge to Windsor, but was not fond of the tunnel under the river of te same name.

I have very fond memories.

Angeline

- Collapse -
Sometimes...
Mar 10, 2010 7:37AM PST

Sometimes it got a little too exciting. I'm thinking of the race riots in June 1943. Eventually, Federal troops restored order.

- Collapse -
(NT) Well, that's excitement.
Mar 10, 2010 8:18AM PST
- Collapse -
Flint (Buick-land) in the same mess.
Mar 19, 2010 6:12AM PDT

High unemployment, and now Medicare cutbacks by the state.

- Collapse -
soon those Medicare cutbacks....
Mar 19, 2010 7:30AM PDT

...will be called Obamacare cutbacks. Wink