and look at "Arrange Icons By" There should be a checkmark on Auto Arrange and Align to grid I have the dot at name also, If you have tried that or it does not help post back. As for the Dupes, how did they get there? Need more info on that.
I have got into a mess with my desk top icons. It started with one going on top of the other and when I tried to put them alphabetically they went all over the place. I then tried to move them and delete the duplicate ones but when I did this I cannot open the shortcuts. It just comes up with the Arrange Icons by.... etc message.
Any ideas please
Using Windows XP Home
Liz

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic