Desktops forum

General discussion

Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

Help!!

I run a small non-profit computer lab. We purchased 25 HP Vectras new in 1999 currently they are all dying on us. We think it's the motherboards. We obviously need to replace these. HPs have been tough for our volunteer help to work on because of the proprietary issues.

I have secured about $8K in grant money to purchase 15-20 CPUs. The HPs were pentiums. We have our own network (running Windows XP professional) and server (running MS Windows Server 2000) and can configure it how we wish.

I need opinions on which option to consider. We have limted funds and need to make them stretch as far as possible. I am considering Celeron because it appears to give me the most bang for the buck.

We will not be offering any heavy duty clases. I will offer a few lite multimedia classes and the kids want to play video games. Our PCs are heavily used because we are located in a community center.

We primarily work with kids from 4 to 18 using MS Office XP, Front Page, and Interactive Learning CD-Roms, etc.

I need advice on the whole processer thing. I hear varying opinions on each and I'm still confused on which is the best buy. I consider myself techy but not hardcore techy so use English please! (LOL)

Also, should I buy ready made or have them built? My lab is down now and I need to get this done ASAP. I'm located in WA State.

Discussion is locked
You are posting a reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?
The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Please refer to our CNET Forums policies for details. All submitted content is subject to our Terms of Use.
Track this discussion and email me when there are updates

If you're asking for technical help, please be sure to include all your system info, including operating system, model number, and any other specifics related to the problem. Also please exercise your best judgment when posting in the forums--revealing personal information such as your e-mail address, telephone number, and address is not recommended.

You are reporting the following post: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?
This post has been flagged and will be reviewed by our staff. Thank you for helping us maintain CNET's great community.
Sorry, there was a problem flagging this post. Please try again now or at a later time.
If you believe this post is offensive or violates the CNET Forums' Usage policies, you can report it below (this will not automatically remove the post). Once reported, our moderators will be notified and the post will be reviewed.
Collapse -
in my opinion...

In reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

and most peoples, Pentiums and AMD are obviously the best. If I were u, I would give a call to Dell or somebody and see if they will give u a good deal for these computers since it is for educational purposes. It is worth a try!!

Collapse -
Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium

In reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

Don't worry about which is better they all do the job, P4 and Athlon will do it faster. You have about $400 to spend per box. I agree with the other post that you should be able to get a deal from Dell,HP,etc.
You didn't say what Pentiums you had? Maybe get 20 new MB for you Pentiums and rebuild them, make it a class project with the older kids. There is a FRY's electronis in Washington good place for parts. John

Collapse -
Don't forget the issue of compatibility.

In reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

A mainboard built in 1999 or before, won't offer support for the new cpu's. In order to upgrade, you'll likely need new mainboard, memory, and cpu.
Not to mention the possibility of extra cooling and most likely, larger psu's.
Consult with a professional to determine the most economical method of accomplishing your goal.

Collapse -
Get them built

In reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

Considering the number of computers needed and the nature of how they will be used, your best bet is to get them built by a large maker where you will be able to have Tech Support and get broken machines replaced quickly. I would call Dell and HP and tell them what you need and ask for a quote. If you want, you can do the same with a local computer store and compare what they offer.

Collapse -
Computer Purchase check up

In reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

Have you found your computers yet?

Collapse -
Question

In reply to: Computer Purchase check up

As I am sure you are aware, the latest technology is moving very fast, so I would consider carefully, how long you wish your new systems to remain. 64 bit has arrived not to speak of different sized sockets for motherboards and cpu's. Also try Monarch computers.

Collapse -
clock speed vs. processing capacity per cycle...

In reply to: Question

The clock speed of a processor (Ghz/Mhz) may be misleading. Different cpus do different amount of work per cycle. Some processor may operate at a higher clock speed, but does less work per cycle, and ends up being slower than another processor that may be operating at a slower clock speed. AMD cpus usually have the highest processing capacity per cycle, Celeron the lowest. That's why many gamers choose AMD over Pentium, even though the fastest Pentium 4 processor operate at a much higher clock.

That said, Celeron looks good for your purposes. It is by far the cheapest.

Collapse -
Still Looking? Here's a suggestion

In reply to: Celeron vs Sempron vs AMD vs Pentium---What is better?

I've been gathering quotes recently for a new computer lab. The best deal I've come across so far has been through HP/Compaq. Call up a sales rep and ask them about the HP d325 tower. This comes as a mini-tower and as a slim tower. This model can be built with the Athlon processor and will probably give you plenty of speed for the applications you will be running. Make sure you request the Athlon processor however, because they will probably try to quote you one with an Intel Pentium or Celeron processor. They built me an excellent system for around $386/per system (without monitor)...$522 with monitor. This is educational pricing, but I wonder if you would be eligible for this? You may want to check since it sounds like you offer some educational types of activities.

Alternately you may want to consider off lease PCs, if you are looking for something really cheap (and reasonably up-to-date). These guys usually offer 90 day warranties. I've bought a couple of Dells this way when I've needed a quick & cheap fix to add additional computers to my organization. Here are a couple of sites:

http://www.hcditrading.com/Shop/Control/fp/SFV/29664
http://www.secondwindpcs.com/index.php

Good Luck!

Collapse -
ideas...

In reply to: Still Looking? Here's a suggestion

i would consider getting it built
Dell can do PC's for under $400 per unit also

i would defintaly consider systems with some of the following CPU's:


Pentium IV (the slow ones, don't go over 2.4GHZ (exception is the LGA 775 2.8, as it's only $154-ish)

Celeron

Celeron D (better than Celeron)

the chip i would actually use if i was you
the AMD Duron

as it's the previous generation value chip
you can get a Duron for $50/CPU @ most retailers
and add in a mid-price nForce2 motherboard with onboard GF4MX gfx, 256-512MB of DDR, and a 40GB HDD

and your set man
just throw in a decent case/PSU combo

you could probalby do it for $250/system

but consider
20 machines will take you some time to build

Popular Forums

icon
Computer Newbies 10,686 discussions
icon
Computer Help 54,365 discussions
icon
Laptops 21,181 discussions
icon
Networking & Wireless 16,313 discussions
icon
Phones 17,137 discussions
icon
Security 31,287 discussions
icon
TVs & Home Theaters 22,101 discussions
icon
Windows 7 8,164 discussions
icon
Windows 10 2,657 discussions

SMART HOME

This one tip will help you sleep better tonight

A few seconds are all you need to get a better night's rest.