18 total posts
So you used the CDROM drive from the other PC?
And the XP CD that worked there?
I've run across where some boot CDs work and the XP CD didn't. At least I could get around that by duplicating the XP CD. Then it worked fine. I then get Microsoft to replace said factory CD if I can.
CD works fine
No such luck at all not sure what the problem is I know it not the CD
Glad to see you solved it.
It is not solved and I cannot get it to work I was telling you that the CD is intact and it works but it will not boot
Then why did you dismiss my findings?
I've run into this situation and found the cure. You wrote your CD was good so I took that as you fixed it.
Maybe you are not looking for possible cures? Sometimes people don't want to try anything at all.
Not sure what else to do
Give a solution I tried everything that I know
I will not try to see if loading the bios off the CD will reset the hardware config...
I am running out of ideas
It's not a solution unless it works.
I take it you don't want ideas. Only the solution.
Sorry but I'd use the known good drive or try a duplicate of the XP CD. But this seems unacceptable to you.
I fear you may end up at a repair counter.
I know you are holding out
No, It is not the drive it worked fine up to when I wanted to erase and do a fresh install....
Now you said to use another drive?
This drive works I just need get it working again there is no way in the matter of hours just be erasing data it goes bad..
Plus I ran a dianostic test it it said the drive was fine
So it's not the cdrom drive.
I don't see how you can be helped if you discount things I've run into before. I don't want to sound mean or such but it's your choice here.
Here's what I've run into.
1. A XP CD that works fine in other machines.
2. The target machine won't boot from it but will boot and read other CDs.
I've solved this one numerous times since I know not to discount anything. I'll duplicate the XP CD and try the dupe. I'll also swap out the CDROM drive since it's a factor.
But you seem to know it's not this or that so how can we get past that and move on to things that have worked for me?
Your doing fine I appreciate your help!
I swapped my Plextor DVD drive in place of a CD ROM drive also I made about 5 copies of the CD last night..
I should have told you all the things I tried but this is the first time I have seen this every...
Save a few turns?
Details like that help dismiss possible cures and leave me room to explore other avenues.
Here's some new ideas.
1. The ntldr issue can occur if the owner had some SATA drive and didn't install XP proper.
2. Booting the XP CD drive has been known to fail with various causes.
a. XP CD (you nixed that.)
b. The drive (I think you got that one.)
c. The drive cable.
d. The drive is not on a stock IDE channel. Try the secondary IDE channel.
e. The drive is not master on the stock IDE channel.
f. There is some other drive on the same channel as the cd drive we want to boot. Remove that.
I'm taking it for granted you have the BIOS set to boot from CD.
Floppy boots fail for numerous reasons. So many that I don't consider this as a valid install method.
Best of luck,
Can you do a DOS copy?
Can you do a DOS copy of the Windows CD Files?
I'll tell you a little story. (Shortened by a large amount)
I got a new laptop, with Windows XP (XP is standard these days). I don't like XP, so, formatted disk and tried to install Windows 2000 - wouldn't install off the CD. Had to do a DOS copy of the files to another disk and install from there, and worked flawlessly. Maybe you can use some of these boot floppies to get a DOS prompt, and then copy from there?
And by the way Robert, using Floppies to boot the computer is just fine as long as disk and drive are in working order.
Post back and we'll see if it worked. Good luck!
Fine if it works.
In this case it's not and the owner didn't reveal the clues until many turns later. There are also other items missing in this post.
Let's be blunt here. XP boots and installs on good hardware. Since this is not the case some hardware is bad or badly configured. But the owner is in denial that "it can't be" this or that. Often we have to leave them to season or simmer a while so they can revisit what it can't be.
getting close I think it is a hardware problem
1. "The ntldr issue can occur if the owner had some SATA drive and didn't install XP proper."
One of the drives are a SATA drive but I had all of them disconnected because I thought that was the problem now I hooked them back up but with now luck.
It would not be the cable since it works fine with other CD's
Tell exactly how you install XP to a SATA drive.
There's a very important step that if you miss it then XP will cough up a ntldr boot error. I don't duplicate read web content on how to install XP to SATA drives but it involves a driver that is not on the XP CD.
Again, why dismiss the cable? This is where many get into trouble. They exclaim "that's not it" and end up at a service counter where some tech will just swap such items because it can always be "it."
We all wish Microsoft would have issued a new XP CD with SATA support. It's a shameful situation.
Hard disk problem
Since none of the XP CDs worked in your case, I am pretty sure you have a SATA 2 hardisk connected on a SATA 1 port (or your motherboard supports only SATA 1). What you can do is open your casing, locate the har disk, and it there is any jumper present, enalbe it for SATA 1 mode, plug back the hdd and reboot with the CDROM inserted in the drive.
Sometimes, windows will not boot from the SATA 2 hdd plugged on a SATA 1 port. Be careful. Please send your feedback if what ive said worked.
Sorry guys for not getting back sooner I solved the problem.....I was doing a quick format which did not completely remove all the data on the HD. In fact for future reference it was a hardware conflict that cause the error but once I did a full format it installed with no hicups..
Thanks all again!!!