Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Can't Decide Which Speaker System To Get, RC Micro or KEF?

Jul 16, 2009 9:26PM PDT

Hi, I am trying to decide what surround sound speaker system to get, I don't want bug bulky speakers so I am trying to go small. I have searched and searched and so far am between the Engergy RC Micro 5.1 sound system or the KEF 3005SE. Both seem great, does the KEF sound any better? I heard that the Energy one sounds amazing for it's size and I've heard the Kef sounds amazing but just not quite up to par with the large big speakers. So, what I want to know is do you think there will be a big sound difference?

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Between the two, I'd lean towards the Energy RC Micro, but
Jul 17, 2009 10:19AM PDT

why is it you are down to comparing just these two? There are a lot of contenders out there.

I'm guessing by the tone of your post that you are in a quandary about two speakers which you have not heard by your unique ears to select what best will please you over time.

I do value reviews such as those from C/NET but my essentials as to speakers are that you must get out to audition possibilities of what is available in your area. It is such an important decision that you must commit to doing it right. It does require some time. Take at least one CD you are intimately familiar with which has some substantial vocals. Vocals are mid-range frequencies but deceptively difficult to reproduce well.

Take basic notes as confusion comes oh so easily. Trust your instincts. If it seems you just heard some distortion - you did. If the speaker does not reproduce vocals well, don't even proceed to consider bass & treble. A note: Your listening area will never sound the same as the audio display room.

No list can be perfect, but perhaps you need some fast broadening of your speaker awareness. The Feb 2008 free online Playback mag had a fine concise list in their article on Bookshelf speakers under $1000. Check it out at: http://magazine.playbackmag.net/playback/200802/?u1=texterity

Hopefully you do not live in the boonies because I have planned vacations in the past to visit big city audio stores. A big city area will have about a dozen brands worth serious consideration. With some time one candidate will rise to the top in your mind as being the best overall. Perhaps I could recommend quite well. So what? That would just be my opinion, not your unique selection.

Remember, the goal is your long term enjoyment.

- Collapse -
Apparently the link no longer works.
Jul 17, 2009 10:22AM PDT

Get directly by going to Playback magazine then they have a list of review articles. It was in Feb 2008 issue.

- Collapse -
Thanks for the info...
Jul 17, 2009 11:52AM PDT

Hi, you're right on that I haven't heard either systems with my own ears, I've just gone by reviews. I went to Playback Magazine and it seems they want me to register before I can see any articles. The reason I guess why I was between those two systems was because I want something first off not too large, then I was going for the best sound possible in that size group and I wanted to get the speakers + bass together rather then the bass separately. I read that the Energy RC and the KEF got very well rated, as well as the Mirage MX 5.1 which I am pretty sure is a division of Klipsch. I was sort of overwhelmed and just started narrowing it down by the reviews and release dates of systems. I also read that the Canton sounds very good. I see your point though that each one is going to sound differently and it is somewhat of a personal preference. What I am going to be using the speakers for is mainly Hi-Def movies and music from my iPod. I am planning to hook whatever speakers I get to the Pioneer VSX-1019AH-K, so if there is a particular systems that sounds great with that receiver I'd go with it.

This is really my first time shopping for a home theater system. I've always gone in the past with a pretty low line home theater system in a box, but this time I am trying to make a really nice home theater.

Any recommendations on systems would be great, what speakers do you like? I live in Maine so there are audio places around with a decent selection of speakers so maybe I should go start listening.

Also, do you think there is a big difference between 5.1 and 7.1 surround sound?

Thanks!!!!!

- Collapse -
Most have their opinion. Many figure the more the better,
Jul 17, 2009 12:32PM PDT

but I am of the other opinion & most disks sound is offered in 5.1 with 7.1 being rather rare. Some love their surround sound. I have basic surround for the main TV in the living room. I am one of the old timers who still prefer "old fashioned" two channel stereo for my music, & I am not alone. Yes, we have evolved from the time that we lusted to invest in the two highest quality speakers we could afford. Home theater is largely about surround rather than primary speaker quality. I don't really think two more side speakers offer a lot more than already using five plus sub woofer. I'd rather see people use the extra increment of money to get a really good sub woofer. The best sub woofers are made by firms specializing in them. Check into HSU, SVS & Outlaw. In this case good requires $300-$500.

Yeah, I remember now that Playback mag required filling in some spaces. I did that probably at least two years ago & have not been spammed by that to the best of my knowledge. Right, not bothered by them.

There is not just a few good speakers. Many, many brands are in that business. First of all, don't hesitate to look beyond just the big box stores like Beat Buy. Independents don't carry dozens of brands but will likely have some nice speaker line to listen to. Independents already survived the intrusion of the big box stores. Their staff is usually a lot better informed.

Yeah, your ears are not the same of mine. Yours are the ones to please.

The thing about selecting your speakers is that the name brand quality ones can be started with thinking about a limited budget because you can start with just two & stick to the same brand & model line & add on as budget permits. I just don't think you can do justice to selecting speakers by good reviews. Yeah, they can provide a starting point.

At normal, average audio needs a receiver really needs not to be fancy & expensive. Decent for most needs really is $250-$275 or so. The electronics are intended to perform without coloring the sound & on a practical level, they do. On the other hand, most all the sound difference will be because of the speakers. That's why they are so important. Don't buy a pig in a poke.

Good wishes for your enjoyment.

NM_Bill.

- Collapse -
Thanks so much.
Jul 23, 2009 1:56AM PDT

Thanks a lot for all the suggestions and help, sorry I didn't reply sooner! I will go around my local stores and preview different ones and then decide. Your input was very helful, thanks again...