Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Buying advice for my Mom...Mac or Windows (long ramble)

Jul 15, 2006 12:18AM PDT

I have been a PC user for 5 years and am familiar and comfortable with Windows. Never tried a Mac.

My 71 year old Mom has never used a computer, but is interested in getting a Notebook (space considerations) since so much information now is only available on the Web. She claims she isn't interested in email, only web surfing, but I think once she sees what a computer can do, she would do more.

She and my Dad are the types who never bought a VCR, DVD player, cell phone, or answering machine because they didn't think they needed them and were afraid of the buying process for electronic gadgets. Over the years my brother and sister and I have moved them into the 20th century (and now the 21st) by buying and setting these items up for them. Surprise, they admit they like them! However, they are still a little afraid of something going wrong and not being able to get them working again.

Now, the biggie: A Computer. There is so much talk on the radio and TV about getting Viruses, Trojans, Spyware, Hackers and Spam (and bears, Oh My!) that my Mom is a bit concerned about getting a computer and someone stealing her identity or it self distructing on her. But, she has resigned herself the the fact that it's worth the hassel if I can help buy it, show her how to use it, and help her out (as much as I can) with maintenance/tech support.

Now, what to get. I have always been intrigued with Macs and thought one might be good for my Mom since I always hear they have a more intuitive OS, are less susceptible to all the above listed problems. The image of them is that they are easy to use and just plain more fun, especially for someone who's never touched a computer. Problem is that I have zero experience with Macs and would have no idea how to help her set it up, use it, or support it. If we went with a Windows-based notebook I could help her more, at least initially. I do admit, and have posted about, wanting to try an iMac but haven't had the time to try one out and still am apprehensive about a few possible unforseen compatiblity issues. I'm tempted to make my Mom the Guinea Pig to see if I like Macs or not, but don't think that's fair if it doesn't work out.

How difficult is a MacBook to learn for the both of us at the same time, or stay with what I know?

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Just for virus/trojan/other, the Mac is back.
Jul 15, 2006 12:43AM PDT

You should catch the fun discussion in the Mac forum about antivirus and more since it's a different world. Even when you reinstall the MacOSX you don't have to lose all your files like Microsoft seems to think is normal.

Go get a demo.

Bob

- Collapse -
Mac mom
Jul 15, 2006 1:24AM PDT

Sounds like perfect timing to me. Your mom doesn't have any preconcieved notions on a computer and you want to try a mac. Get her a mac and learn together. It's not that hard. I just switched. I still have a windows laptop too. If she doesn't like it you can buy it from her and your good to go for a nice laptop. It will give yourself another excuse to visit your mother.

- Collapse -
I've Experienced A Mac
Jul 15, 2006 3:23PM PDT

Now that there is Core Duo on a Mac they are really fast. It's quite easy. Say you're looking for something that contains "dog". Go to the bar at the top right corner and type it in. It comes up with documents that contain the word you're looking for. And it's true there's barely any viruses. My favorite is Windows and Tiger on 1 machine. So you can help her with Windows and Tiger all using 1 notebook. The only thing is price. But just think. Preinstalled software is what makes others cheaper. So if you take away preinstalled software the notebooks that you think are cheap go up another $250-600. So go Mac and buy Windows while you're at it!