alexflux,
I'm sorry to hear that you're having these issues. We're reporting the discs that have issues as they come in so that we can address these titles and the compatibility.
--HDTech
Two recent blu-ray discs that I rented (Book of Eli and Observe and Report) did not play on my Samsung BP1600. I even got a replacement of O&R, but it had the same problem. Basically, I put the disc in, the previews play, and then once it gets to the movie itself, I get no menu, I cannot get it to play by pressing play. All I see on the TV screen is a frozen image (that disc with a shadow of a disc).
Other Blu-ray discs (e.g., Sony, 20th c. fox) play without a glitch.
Any one have any tips on what to do/try? It is ridiculous to have to skip renting blu-ray discs from WB because of this problem.

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic