Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Batteries

May 15, 2007 7:07AM PDT

Should the battery a camera uses be a factor in your digital camera selection? I've noticed some take alkaline (AA) and some use lithium. What difference does it make? How does it effect the camera performance?

Thanks
Beth

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Batteries
May 15, 2007 9:55AM PDT

Some cameras use a lithium battery.
Some come with alkaline AA batteries.
Most people will buy rechargeable NiMH AA batteries and a charger.
About $20.
The alkaline AA batteries do not last long.

The NIMH batteries will last about as long on a charge as the lithium batteries.

Type of battery does not affect camera performance.

I have cameras with both types of batteries.
To me.....it is a don't care situation.
I don't consider the type of battery when buying a camera.
Why limit your choices with something that does not matter.

...
..
.

- Collapse -
yes, but not the only or a major factor
May 16, 2007 11:34AM PDT

AFAIK from some research and advice from store employees
If a digicam comes with non-rechargeable batts.....
It'll take:
1) Non rechargeable alkalines batts
2) Rechargeable alkalines batts
3) Non rechargeable lithion ion (li-ion) batts

it woN'T take
4) rechargeable lithion ion (li-ion) batts, since these are proprietary to custom fit the digicams they were made for

Most of these digicams come w/a cheaper, less capcity version of #1 that lasts a pitifully short time. Getting high capacity #1s (i think that's around 2200mAH?) will last much longer than any included batts, is the cheapest of the 3 types above, but doesn't give best performance. E.g., u get 500 shots off a set of #1s, but but about halfway to 2/3 the way through, there won't be enough charge to power the flash, or sufficiently so, just enough for nonflash shots.

#2 has less capacity overall, but u save more $$ since u can reuse the same batts over and over again for its lifecycle duration. After about x amt of charges, performance likely to go down like described with #1 above. If you run out of juice for #2 batts but can't recharge, swap in #1 & #3 to supplement your shooting needs till u get home and can charge

#3 Noticeably more expensive, but still manageable in cost. Highest capacity, and power output is great. Towards the end of the batts lifecycle, you'll get roughly at least 90% of output, so u can still squeeze max power for flahs and any other power hungry features


PROS
-ALL these batteries come in std sizes like AA, AAA, etc. If u need fresh batt on the fly, buying from a general store or "tourist trap" is an option. Or just pack extras.
-The rechargeable alkaline will be more readily avialable from bigger and/or more batt oriented stores like Targe, RadioShack, and special elextronics stores
-no need to carry charger

CONS
-not the best performance in a batt for non li-ion
-replacing batt often has environmental effects
-can get quite expensive if you take pictures VERY often and have to replace batt alot
-either get better li-ion performance or convenience of rechargeable alkalines, but NOT both

If a digicam comes with rechargeable
it will take
4) rechargeable lithion ion (li-ion) batts, since these are proprietary to custom fit the digicams they were made for

they MAY or may NOT take:
1) Non rechargeable alkalines batts
2) Rechargeable alkalines batts
3) Non rechargeable lithion ion (li-ion) batts

IIRC, some models that use #4 may also allow for #1 through #3 std batteries as an alternative when someth goes wrong w/#4. Check with the manufacturer or consult the digicam in question's user manual for more info

PROS
-great performance w/convenience of recharging
-cost effective when taking many pics

CONS
-need to bring a charger with u on vacations/trips
-a spare #4 may be needed for heavy use, which are typically expensive (around $50, but vary per model.)
-can only buy from manuf or their authorized dealer
-need to remember to keep batts charged
-if u lose #4 or they go defective, u may not have an alternative

CONCLUSION
Unless you're trigger happy w/your camera, case #1 should suffice. Else case #2 may be better. Else, there r a few scenarios where both'll suffice, in which that's up to u to decide

Happy hunting