Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Basic Internet Service: Comcast Cable Vs. Verizon DSL

Jul 19, 2011 10:02AM PDT

I received a new price increase with my current internet
service provider (Comcast). As a result, I was interested in checking with
Verizon to see how their service compares in terms of price and transmission
speed. It turns out that in my area
Verizon offers a DSL service with 5 mbps connection; and, it is also a few
dollars cheaper than my new monthly rate with Comcast.


I contacted Comcast to see if they could match the Verizon offer. The customer
representative indicated that they could do no better in terms of their new
rate increase or connection speed. In addition, the Customer Service
Representative at Comcast indicated that my current connection speed with
Comcast is 3.5 mbps.


Before deciding whether or not to change to Verizon, I am wondering if anyone has
seen a difference in connection speeds - between Comcast Cable and Verizon
internet service? (The customer service
representative at Comcast indicated that the connection speeds via cable are
likely to be faster than DSL.) Also, has
anyone found a significant difference in the customer service for Verizon and
Comcast?


I should also mention that I only use Comcast for the basic internet service;
and, I have a separate VOIP provider.

Thanks for reading this post!

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
So you're going for RAW DSL?
Jul 19, 2011 11:04AM PDT

Be sure you of your quotes. Sorry I've been on Verizon's DSL at that speed. Cable here is all of 10megabit and feels much faster than 10 divided by 6. And my monthly rate is 66 bucks a month for phone and net.
Bob

- Collapse -
Switching to DSL
Jul 20, 2011 10:14AM PDT

Hi Bob - based on your email, i'm not sure if you're happy with cable or Dsl. Did you have both? If yes, have you noticed a speed difference?
Thanks-
Todd

- Collapse -
Had both. Was glad to move back to cable.
Jul 20, 2011 10:19AM PDT

I even had FIOS at 27 megabit for 3 or 4 months and even this 10 megabit seems much faster than 1/2 that fios speed.

Let me be clear. I'd go to DSL if I was in a pinch but 33 a month is great here.
Bob

- Collapse -
Verizon Fioss
Jul 20, 2011 6:52PM PDT

I'm not sure if it is available in your area, but if Fios is available, it is AMAZING. I have had Comcast and I'm sorry to say Fios is killing it. I ordered the 25/25 internet figuring there was no need for 35/35. I've run many different tests including Ping/Jitter/Latency tests. With other apps open I'm averaging right around 17mbps down, 16mbps up, Ping at 29ms, 0% packet loss and 1-2 jitter (which I'm not happy with) There are 4 computers and a Sony bravia TV on the network. So I guess their claim that the number of users and peak times don't affect fiber optic networks. The test is going to be playing PS3 games against my son in FL (I'm in MA). I also get right around the same speeds on my iphone on Wifi. In summary, I am very pleased with Verizon's service. You mentioned only 5mbps service ??? Here, the slowest they offer is 15/5 (down/up). Clarify it their network is fiber optic and if so, enjoy !!!

- Collapse -
Comcast Cable vs Verizon DSL
Jul 21, 2011 9:20AM PDT

Shummm18 - Thanks for the info. i live in a bit of rural area. As such, Fios is not yet available. Otherwise, it would certainly be a good option to pursue. I also have heard things about FIOS that suggests that it is lightning fast.

Regarding the speed of the system, I used the CNET speed check to find out the speed of my connection yesterday. I was a bit surprised ... if I use a WIFI connection, the speed is 1.5 mbps. If I directly hook up to the network with a Cat5 cable, the speed is 10 mbps. I don't know if I believe it - especially since my connection with Comcast is theoretically suppose to max at 3.5 mbps. Are these speed checkers accurate?

- Collapse -
Thanks-
Jul 21, 2011 9:25AM PDT

Bob - I missed the opportunity to thank you for your feedback. Thanks!
Todd