9 total posts
This already exists.
Its a free download for the iPod Touch and iPhone from the app store. Its much better than the horrible little creaky white plastic remote but now that I have a Harmony that does it all I never use it.
As good as the interface is on the Apple TV its still going to take more than a remote overhaul to make it more than a niche product. I use it to watch video podcasts, watch the occasional trailer and to stream music. I like it OK, but I would never recommend it to anyone else without serious qualifications.
Not that the Harmony is perfect. Apple has too few buttons
and Logitech suffers from extreme button overload (and awkwardly placed at that). And the setup software is the very definition of "unintuitive".
Still the macros make it all worth it. If we could just cross Apple's sense of design with the Harmony's endless flexibility you'd have the perfect universal remote.
rly? i thought the software is the easiest ive ever used...
That software was typical Logitech,
lots of buttons and options, very little clarity about how to accomplish a task. It took quite a bit of digging to figure out how do set up some of the tasks (the Apple TV setup was by far the most confusing aspect). This is clearly a company that thinks more stuff is always better.
Once you get it set up it works fine (aside from the weird placement of the buttons on the remote and there needing to be about half as many of them). But the process of getting to that point was not a good experience.
I think Apple remote is perfect
A GUI is where you handle complexity. The physical device should be as simple as possible.
Nothing is wrong with the UI
Simple remote onscreen UI works great. Problem is lack of content, it only works with iTunes. They need to put a blu ray player and a tv tuner in it before people want it.
The iPod never would have taken off if it didn't play your existing CD library.
Amen to that.
<i>The iPod never would have taken off if it didn't play your existing CD library.</i>
This is is the nagging little detail that people forget about when they claim that digital downloads and streaming have already killed off physical media for video. If it wasn't for the ease with which people could get all their pre-existing music into iTunes and thusly onto their iPods the market for mp3 players would have been nowhere near as robust as it was. The lack of DRM on CD's is what allowed the transition to digital music to happen so quickly. Had there been DRM on CD's and the masses not been easily able to transfer their music the history of the iPod would have been very different.
The ATV interface is indeed pretty good... that is when it actually works. Mine crashes and freezes up all the time and requires long restarts. Oh and its always a good time when the devices decides its time to synch with iTunes... right in the middle of remote command, bringing the navigation to a painful crawl.
This Apple fanboy thinks the ATV is the biggest turd Apple has created since Steve Job's return to the company. Such potential but yet its really just a half assed device with a pretty interface.
not arguing the ui or the music. no buttons = fail-mote