Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Anti-virus when runing windows on intel-mac

Mar 6, 2009 6:15PM PST

Hi,
I've just been thinking about installing Windows XP on my MacBook Pro (with leopard), mainly for being able to play all the windows games, and was wondering if I should also install an anti-virus so as to avoid the threats you get on Windows.
My only reason to boot Windows would be for the games (sometimes online ones), so I wanted to know if I should feel safe or not without an anti-virus while running Windows on my Mac. How would you handle such an issue?
Thanks for any answers Happy

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Absolutely, positively, YES!
Mar 6, 2009 9:53PM PST

Even though Windows would be running on the Mac, it is still Windows and still as vulnerable to ALL the nasties out there.

Definitely run AV for Windows

P

- Collapse -
Reposted for Chris
Mar 8, 2009 6:26PM PDT

But without a totally irrelevant link promoting a (his?) site, which isn't allowed here.

"I only have one small problem with my new Mac 24". I'm used to using QuickBooks for all my accounts as it works with my accountants systems. Unfortunately in the UK they don't produce QuickBooks for Mac. I also do a little bit of web design for my internet business and it is very useful to check how the sites appear on Internet Explorer (I can check Firefox, safari etc directly on the Mac but have to open up my old laptop every time for IE). I have discovered (surprise, surprise) that IE is the most incompatible browser out there and it's where all my design problems happen.
So, when money allows, my thoughts are to either get a Mac Book - for holidays, my partner to use etc - and install bootcamp to run Vista, or just get a cheap laptop for those few uses. I'm loathed to let Windows XP anywhere near a beautifully working Mac. Is it worth the extra expense or should I just get a cheap laptop?

Chris Marper"

- Collapse -
If all you want to do
Mar 8, 2009 9:57PM PDT

is use Windows to check IE, then I would go with a very cheap laptop.

If you plan on using it for anything else, as part of your business for instance, I would consider the MB

Could you manage to use QuickBooks if you got the American Mac version?

P

- Collapse -
Quickbooks
Mar 8, 2009 10:44PM PDT

No, I did a bit of research and of course all the tax implications are very different.

I've so enjoyed using my Mac Desktop and with the ability to sync it all with a MacBook it makes it very tempting to go down that route. I have no regrets in my purchase of the 24" Monster as it is great for doing numerous things at once on one screen as well as using Spaces. Just got to take into account the added cost of buying Vista on top of the MacBook purchase.

Ultimately, I haven't looked back though so will probably go down that route and get Bootcamp installed.
For now, I shall just keep firing up my poor old laptop to do my accounts. If I turn it on, take a shower, have a coffee, run the Mrs to work... it's just about ready when i return. Did I mention it was getting a bit slow!!

Chris

- Collapse -
(NT) Slow? I took that as a given!
Mar 8, 2009 11:20PM PDT
- Collapse -
Not online, still AV?
Mar 30, 2009 6:22AM PDT

The poster before mentions "sometimes online games." My intention is to keep all internet connections DISABLED for my XP Bootcamp install. If the computer is booted as OS X (which will still have internet connections) would I really need XP's AV software?

I will only use windows to run windows only software (that does not require an internet connection,) so I would not think AV software is required.

- Collapse -
For Windows a new breed of pest is...
Mar 30, 2009 6:33AM PDT

Jumping around using the common USB MEMORY STICK. It's sad but that was a BIG CHINK in the armor. Most machines blindly autorun CD, DVD and USB memory sticks.

It appears you can't do without unless you are willing to take the chance.
Bob

- Collapse -
Oh yeah.
Mar 30, 2009 7:01AM PDT

My advanced digital teacher was talking about that not three hours ago. Thanks for reminding me about that, R. Proffitt Happy

Thanks for the quick reply, too.

- Collapse -
Get the anti virus
Mar 13, 2009 7:18PM PDT

(I'd send this one over to the security forum.) Whether running on a Mac or a PC the Windows OS would still be vulnerable. My guess is hardware attacks might be reduced slightly but not by much, if any. This would depend on the hardware infected and the virus and how it was written.

- Collapse -
thx for tips
Mar 23, 2009 12:17AM PDT

Ok, well ill just install some protection then. however, I'd also like to know if it is possible to simply erase to Windows partition if it ever gets infected (just by using Boot Camp), so as to eradicate the virus from my computer. I hope that if a virus attacks me while im running Windows it'll only be the Windows part of my disk that gets damaged...

- Collapse -
Boot Camp
Mar 23, 2009 1:06AM PDT

there is a function within Boot Camp that allows you to destroy the Windows partion completely.

P