Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Another useful folk remedy (?) -- Honey for wound healing

May 28, 2007 12:48AM PDT
Topical Honey As A Possible Treatment For Diabetic Ulcers.

>> The sore on Catrina Hurlburt's leg simply wouldn't heal. Complications from a 2002 car accident left Hurlburt, a borderline diabetic, with recurring cellulitis and staph infections. One of those infections developed into a troublesome open sore that, despite the use of oral antibiotics, continued to fester for nearly eight months.

Then Hurlburt's physician, Jennifer Eddy of UW (The University of Wisconsin) Health's Eau Claire Family Medicine Clinic, suggested she try using topical honey. Within a matter of months, the sore had healed completely. "I remember thinking, holy mackerel-what a difference," says Hurlburt, who can't use topical antibiotics because of allergies. "It's a lot better than having to put oral antibiotics into your system."

With funding provided by the Wisconsin Partnership Fund for Health and the American Academy of Family Physicians Foundation, Eddy is currently conducting the first randomized, double-blind controlled trial of honey for diabetic ulcers. Eddy first successfully used honey therapy a few years ago with a patient who was facing amputation after all medical options had been exhausted. Experts believe that treating wounds with honey has tremendous potential for the approximately 200 million people in the world with diabetes, 15 percent of whom will develop an ulcer, usually because of impaired sensation in their feet. <<

This will be a terrific advance if confirmed!

-- Dave K, Speakeasy Moderator
click here to email semods4@yahoo.com

The opinions expressed above are my own,
and do not necessarily reflect those of CNET!

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
Insulin and sugar
May 28, 2007 1:26AM PDT

I wonder if they've ever considered injecting such areas with insulin bound sugars. Normally insulin is taken and then binds with sugars in the body which then allows the sugar to enter cells which require insulin to be the key which opens the cells for the exchange. For problem areas why not bind the insulin and sugar first outside the body and then inject directly in those problem areas.


As for sugar, syrup or honey in a wound, I think it works several ways. It's a preservative like when done for sugar cured hams. It also encourages beneficial yeast in an area which may give protection against invasive destructive bacteria like gangrene. The body's cells will take some of the energy in directly and be energized to more efficiently accomplish the necessary task.

The best way to get rid of continual staph germ infections is sulfur powder daily, about third teaspoon, for a few weeks, sometimes a couple months is necessary. There's this newer sulfur compound called MSM that may do as well and be more absorbable, but don't know if it will do the same.

- Collapse -
MSM
May 28, 2007 7:52AM PDT

Used it for severe Arthritis pain and joint stiffness. So bad in all three segments of spine, joints and connective tissue that I could barely get by without home aid, much less work. I first learned about MSM from my Chiropractor. Turned out the powder MSM has had miraculous effect. While it took a few months for full swing effect, I found that when I would stop using it I'd just end up back where I started. And would have to start the MSM treatment all over.

As I understand it, MSM (Methyl Sulfonyl Methane) some how softens cellular outer lining, or walls permitting nutrients to enter and toxins and waste to exit. These walls generally harden as we age. And while some MSM is available in some meats and vegetables, that it is not enough. Don't let "Methane" scare you. While it used to be derived from Petroleum, it is now derived from Pine trees.

The best as far as I can tell from personal experience is powder MSM which seems to be the most expensive at about $40 a pound. Next, crystal (chelate) at about $10 a lb. In tablet form the least expensive, and while a bit helpful, not very. The powder and crystal I have only been able to find online.

The first few days of using the powder or crystal (chelate) seems to produce a short, mild buzz as many built-up toxins are being flushed through and from the body.

Charlie

- Collapse -
my knees
May 28, 2007 10:23PM PDT

About 10 years ago I had some problem with "rice krispie" knees. They went "snap, crackle, pop" and some problem on stairs. I don't even know if they had the chondroitin sulfate out then, but I was taking some sulfur to help and added liquid jello and the problems went away in a few weeks, almost like a miracle. It was my own doing or maybe prompted by instinct. I figured since jello was basically liquid cartilage, maybe it would help me repair my own. I don't like eating it, so I'd dissolve half a small box with the boiling water, add ice to quickly cool it, then drink it instead of putting in refrigerator and letting it set. Suprisingly, it makes an interesting and refreshing drink.

A couple months ago I turned out my right knee or did something to it and been using cane during that time. First problem I've had since 10 years ago with my knees. I went to see an orthapedic surgeon Leigh Curl who is the one for the Baltimore Ravens team. I was worried I had a swollen bursa, leaky synovial fluids or jerked a ligament loose. X-ray showed loss of cartilage in the right inner knee area, but no surgery at this time. On the good side, no osteo, my bones were like stones. Prescription? Over the counter "Osteo Bi-flex" and let it heal, check back in 2 months. Wife picked up some jello again this week and I'll be back on that again for awhile too since the holiday and relatives visiting are finished.

My one complaint about the pills which contain MSM, Glucosamine, Frankinsense oils, (boswellia) chondroitin, collagen (hydrolzyed gelatin, aka jello) is, I think the MSM causes worst gas problems and worse smelling too than just taking elemental sulfur which can be purchased without prescription from a pharmacy. When I used sulfur, I had "rotten egg" type gas for about first 3 days, then it would go away. These pills are HUGE.

- Collapse -
That's interesting
May 28, 2007 11:18PM PDT

I've noticed a bit of noise in my neck, which concerns me a bit. You might be able to hear it with a stethoscope. Maybe I'll try the jello stuff.

- Collapse -
I tried honey for my aching knees,
May 29, 2007 3:46AM PDT

but it wouldn't rub off the extra 30 lbs. I carry on them. Happy

But seriously, folks. I'll save your post because it has some things I hadn't heard about for joint problems. (I have osteoarthritis which doesn't bother me much, but I'm always looking ...)
I used the MSM stuff for a while and never noticed a gas problem.
The rotten-egg odor is hydrogen sulphide or a related product, not elemental sulphur. You must have some elves running a strange chemical lab in your gut. Happy
The Knox people have been selling plain gelatin for years for 'stronger fingernails' on the same principle as your Jello. You might try it.

- Collapse -
Excerpts from "Honey-The Bee's Gift to Man"
May 28, 2007 8:37PM PDT

from Awake! of 8/8/05

"... In addition to being a marvelous food-a veritable storehouse of B vitamins, various minerals, and antioxidants-honey is one of the oldest known medicines in continuous use. Dr. May Berenbaum, an entomologist with the University of Illinois, U.S.A., comments: "Honey has been used for centuries to treat a wide range of medical problems like wounds, burns, cataracts, skin ulcers and scrapes." ... It was noted that [butn] patients had a faster healing time and less pain and scarring when honey dressings were used [in the hospital, not in the field as first aid].

Studies show that because of an enzyme added to the nectar by the bees, honey has mild antibacterial and antibiotic properties. This enzyme generates hydrogen peroxide, which kills harmful bacteria. (Since the enzyme is destroyed by heating and exposure to light, unpasteurized honey is used for medicinal purposes.) Additionally, applied topically, honey has been found to reduce inflammation and to promote the growth of healthy tissue. Thus, New Zealand biochemist Dr. Peter Molan says: "Honey is becoming accepted as a reputable and effective therapeutic agent by practitioners of conventional medicine." In fact, the Australian Therapeutic Goods Administration has approved honey as a medicine, and medical honey is being marketed as a wound dressing in that country."

Article also had some useful notes on cooking with honey in place of sugar.

- Collapse -
honey
May 28, 2007 10:28PM PDT

Sounds good medicine. Honey can sit for a long time on a shelf and still be good, self preserving. One of my daughters likes to have it on those Popeye biscuits. I haven't had any in a while, but just talking about it making me a bit hungry for some, lol.

- Collapse -
Yep
May 28, 2007 11:16PM PDT

Honey is impervious to bacteria. Probably to viruses, too.

- Collapse -
but can be fermented with yeast
May 29, 2007 2:42AM PDT
- Collapse -
"Mead - The bee's gift to Viking berserkers."
May 29, 2007 4:05AM PDT

NOT likely in one of our mags. Happy

I had some years ago and noticed that it's so smooth you can be on your fourth stein by the time you realize that the second was one too many.

- Collapse -
"probably for viruses" might not be worth
May 29, 2007 4:16AM PDT

betting the farm on because they're so different, physically and biologically.
That said, I'm inclined to agree with you. Remember that the number one topical treatment for viruses (aside from avoidance) is ordinary chlorine bleach; drugstore H2O2 is also a bleach and disinfectant. And the consensus of the posts here is that the honey puts a protective coating on the boo-boo area during healing, without allowing any bad developments underneath.

- Collapse -
I probably should have included this
May 29, 2007 2:31PM PDT

from my first post:
""Honey isn't for everybody, however," cautions the report. It is estimated that botulism spores are present in up to 5 percent of honey. Such agencies as Health Canada's Botulism Reference Service as well as pediatric societies advise against giving honey to children under one year of age because "infants have not yet developed sufficient intestinal microflora to protect them from the bacterium.""

Same thought; more specifics. That 5% must be pretty good odds, given how many parents must be giving honey to their infants just to "make the medicine go down".

- Collapse -
Another use:
May 29, 2007 3:55AM PDT

Here in NM many of us - native and immigrant - have pollen allergies. It's the custom to pass around honey from the local hives as a 'hair of the dog' remedy. Also bee pollen ditto. It's supposed to work for some, but I always had an allergic reaction to more than a couple of grains of pollen (possibly verifying the idea), but I never noticed any improvement from the honey.

Speaking of tastes, I love honey in my tea, but NEVER in my coffee.

- Collapse -
Try sandwiches with
May 29, 2007 7:08AM PDT

peanut butter and honey or just butter and honey instead of jelly or jam. The downside is that honey tends to want to continuously make us aware of the laws of gravity. It seeps and oozes ever so slowly downward. Ever wonder why a honeyjar is always stuck to the surface when you go to pick it up? Keeping the sandwich in constant rotation helps. You can lick the seepage from your hands and fingers but from your shirt and trousers is sort of uncouth. Happy

- Collapse -
honey with the hot cereals in the winter
May 29, 2007 12:39PM PDT

porridge, semolina and tapioca all improve with honey Happy

also a spoon of honey stirred into a salad dressing or added to the vinegar when you make pickles will add a lot


jonah "reincarnation of Winnie the Pooh" jones


.,

- Collapse -
Goes good on grits.
May 29, 2007 2:43PM PDT

And when it gloms up with the Cheerios it makes candy.

- Collapse -
"Uncouth"
May 29, 2007 2:37PM PDT

is what they call me every time I do it. Happy