9 total posts
PS - link to original story
History tells us that most conflicts end in chaos
By John Keegan
What monopolises the headlines and prime time television at the moment is news from Iraq on the activity of small, localised minorities struggling to entrench themselves before full peace is imposed and an effective state structure is restored. The news is, in fact, very repetitive: disorder in Najaf and Fallujah, misbehaviour by a tiny handful of US Army reservists - not properly trained regular soldiers - in one prison. There is nothing from Iraq's other 8,000 towns and villages, nothing from Kurdistan, where complete peace prevails, very little from Basra, where British forces are on good terms with the residents.
I have been recovering from major surgery for the past few weeks and so have overdosed myself on daytime television - Richard and Judy, Crucible snooker, I Want that House, A Place in Greece. Most of it is entirely forgettable. There is, however, an undeniable fascination in watching Jon Snow, of Channel 4 News, energise himself for his early evening denunciation of Anglo-American activity in Iraq. About 5.30 he comes on to rehearse his sense of outrage. At 7pm we get the full display of apoplexy and hysteria - raised voice, flushed face, physical trembles.
... Iraq 2004 is not Greece 1945, not Indochina 1946-54, not Algeria 1953-62 and certainly not "Vietnam".
username/email == email@example.com
password == kerry666
A companion read
Would that those who claim extensive expertise actually have that about which they speak.
As you and Evie point out, a knowledge of history would be good for starters.
Re:An interesting read -- 'Iraq History Lesson'
Wouldn't it be nice if the media REPORTED the news rather than trying to MAKE it?
It would be nice if the media reported all of the news instead of just reporting the bad news.
I can't remember the last time, if ever, that I saw a smiling Iraqi citizen in the news, particularly the american news. We've been bombarded for weeks on end over the horrendous actions of a half a dozen soldiers (cretins) at Abu Ghraib but we hear nothing of the positive efforts of the other 160,000 troops in Iraq.
The media fails to reports that all 240 hospitals and 95% of the clinics have reopened with health care spending 26 times what it was under Saddam.
The media fails to report that the CPA has spent $9 million to clear over 18,500 kilometers of irrigation canals that were previously weed choked from years of neglect to bring water thousands of farmers.
The media fails to report that the CPA has provided funding to repair more than 1,040 schools, built playgrounds and sports fields, provided youth centers, and repaired child care centers. The Coalition Provisional Authority and Iraqi workers built a new school in Hilla, Babil Province. Liberation School, so named by local school officials, will provide more than 400 boys and girls an opportunity to attend primary school in their own neighborhood.
The media fails to report that the Humanitarian Assistance Coordination Center (HACC), operated by the Polish Army, has provided medicine, food, and toys to the Iraqi people. The HACC donated 450 cartons of antibiotics and painkillers to hospitals in Hilla and Al Kut. Toys collected by Polish children were distributed by HACC to Iraqi children at a primary school in Hilla. The Polish Army also donated 1,200 kg of food to villages near Karbala and an orphanage in Hilla.
The media fails to report anything even remotely positive achieved by the majority of troops in Iraq. Why doesn't the media report the on progress made for the benefit of the Iraqi people? Why does the media seem intent in smearing america at every chance it gets? Me thinks the media is a disgrace and should be ashamed of itself. I, for one, turned away from the TV and radio media for my news long ago. I would just as soon spend my time searching for the news that interests me instead of taking the crap they want to feed me.
Conspicuous by their absence - the nay sayers
expected but disappointing none the less.
(NT) NAY!!! NAY!! ;-)
Clever Josh and appreciated ;-)
any comment on the history lesson or its accuracy in remarking the inaccuracies of your past comments regarding quagmire, no government, etc.? (I say YOUR because you were the only self proclaimed nay sayer who had the courage of his convictions to answer even if in joshing.)