I own the dish 811 system with the hi-def over the air tuner built in. and its hot I receive 18 local hi-def channels with a cheap outside antenna. I pay $45.00 per month fo VOOM , Hi-def package and basic service. and I have tons of hi-def channels to watch I use the d.v.i. output and optical audio for stunning picture and sound, Dont bother with h.b.o. or showtime because you only get one of those in hi-def Also if you go for Dish e mail me and I will send you a gift # for free upgrades and goddies and I receive $5.00 of my bill for a year I have givin away 4 of these gift # and I save $20.00 per month marry xmas stewart norrie cadillacstew@aol.com
Seems to me that a built in tuner is the way to go... fewer pieces of equipment, fewer cables, fewer connections, right? I read somewhere that set-top tuners were a better investment because they could change the HD standards in two years and make TVs with built in tuners obsolete, whereas you can easily swap set-top boxes if that happens.
What's the real deal?

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic