Thank you for being a valued part of the CNET community. As of December 1, 2020, the forums are in read-only format. In early 2021, CNET Forums will no longer be available. We are grateful for the participation and advice you have provided to one another over the years.

Thanks,

CNET Support

General discussion

Advice for buying a $200 HIBT system?

Feb 26, 2006 11:28AM PST

Could anyone advice a newbie HTIB buyer?

I am totally newbie to audio, but I would I always would like make an informed decision. I am looking for a home theater system to play DVD's (maybe hook up to computer and do HDTV in the future)that costs MAX $250. I did all the research I could in the internet and am considering the following. If anyone knows anything about particular model or even the brand in general I'd love to hear your advice. I am considering:

Samsung HT-WP38, $200, 800W (I really don't need the DVD player, as I have on already, and I don;t know if samsung is as good in audio as it is in TVs , but the wireless speakers and usb port are welcome. On the other hand, it only has optical digital input, no coax digital input - is that a problem?)

Pioneer HTP-2500,$200, 1000W (lots of wats, but I don't need loud music. Pricey considering it doesn't have wireless rear speakers [has pre out puts, what ever that means])

SONY HT-DDW670, $159 600W (Good price)

Panasonic SC-HT05 , $150 (claims to have 1% THD, when other systems have 10%. How is that possible, when they compete in same price (=cost)range? Also , the amp is in the subwooofer, where as the other systems have the amp in the receiver)

or Logitech Z-5450, $250, 300w (THX certified - does that really mean anything except that the price is higher because of the cost? This is supposed to be a computer system, will it be enough for a 250sq ft room? Am I over paying because it targets a computer gamer niche?)

Thanks for any help, and let me know where to post this if I posted this to the wrong place.

Discussion is locked

- Collapse -
SPEAKERS SPEAKERS SPEAKERS
Feb 26, 2006 12:14PM PST

You can buy a cheepie 5.1. amp. but you cannot be cheap on speakers. I would look at other posts in this chat room and you will understand why cheap speakers wont make you happy. and dont even think about BOSE read on stewart

- Collapse -
Sony
Feb 26, 2006 1:36PM PST

At that price, you are not going to get a high quality home theater system. I have listened to some of these systems in the stores and think the Sony has the best overall sound. Actually has a decent sub, even if it is passive. Also, it is not very expensive, so when you decide to upgrade to seperates, you are not out much money. Remember, you will not be able to upgrade any of these HTIBs.

The best thing you can do is let your ears decide. Compare them side by side if you can. Most of these systems have tinny sounding surrounds and boomy bass. Pick something that sounds more natural musically.

Forget the power rating, they do not compare with what you get in a seperate surround receiver. Once again, listen, listen, listen. Forget the specs, all that matters is a sound that you like.

- Collapse -
it depends on what u want
Feb 26, 2006 3:49PM PST

the logitechs are great speakers. but it limits you quite a bit and will never get you true surround sound cause it relys on a sound card to process the sound first which you dont have. on the bright side, you're getting some of the best computers speakers out there.

the panasonic is just OLD but it is a very good budget system. i'd definitely recommend it. i just hate the fact that it requires a propriatery cable that connects the reciever to the sub that prevents you from putting the subwoofer close to the couch.

the good thing about the sony is that it does have 2 DIGITAL inputs plus a lot more stereo inputs, but the speakers are definitely NOT the hottest thing in the world. especially when its just a passive subwoofer, theres just no fullness in the sound.

the samsung is a good little unit, but again the speakers are a little weak and connections are limited.

amazon.com has the yamaha yht-160 on sale for $250. power sub which does fill up the room to a certain extent. 3 digital audio inputs, plus a lot of rca inputs. a/b speaker switching. even has component switching too for your HD (if u ever need it). this yamaha is definitely the one if would recomend if you dont mind spending a few more dollars for a much better product.

- Collapse -
Thanks
Feb 27, 2006 10:24AM PST

Thanks for your advice everyone, especially Masterying01. I appreciate evaluation of each of the systems. Sounds like Panasonic is best for the money, but I'll look seriously into the Yamaha as well. So that I got it right, Logitech doesn't play real surround w/o computer and card, right - unlike the other systems. And only Yamaha is HDTV ready (I still have to look up what exactly that requires)
Thanks!!

- Collapse -
Wait and buy quality
Feb 26, 2006 4:45PM PST

You may not want your music loud but you still will want quality sound. HTIB, is a quick fix. And like any quick fix its only going to deliver short term. My advice keep saving then go to B&H photo for a great price on speakers.

- Collapse -
One option might be KLIPSCH PRO-MEDIA speakers......
Feb 28, 2006 1:24PM PST

Really for Computers but might do in a pinch.
Like others have indicated, save YOUR MONEY, and get
something of higher-quality. Best wishes;

river.