Are you saying that you have an operating system on both drives? As such, you would need to select the boot drive from your motherboard BIOS. When you log on, you are doing so to an operating system and not to a drive itself. Now, I would be careful if you've installed the same copy of XP using the same product ID on both drives. That might confuse the MS validation process when you go on line to update the OS.
Some clarification is needed here.
I recentley added a hard drive to my pc. A Dell 4500 series I bought in 2002. My OS is XP HE SP2. 1.8 pros.,640 ram. I can access the new drive ok when I open it from My Computer. I can view the folders. What I want to do is Log on to the new hard drive as I would before I added the new drive. The new drive is loaded with XP. I want to log on using the normal welcome screen and use it in the normal fashion. Is that possible and how is that done? Any help would be greatley appreciated...Thanks

Chowhound
Comic Vine
GameFAQs
GameSpot
Giant Bomb
TechRepublic