X
CNET logo Why You Can Trust CNET

Our expert, award-winning staff selects the products we cover and rigorously researches and tests our top picks. If you buy through our links, we may get a commission. Reviews ethics statement

Heart-shaped steak and more of Goldbelly's best Valentine's Day eats

Order up a little romance with these easy Valentine's Day eats and sweets for your loved one.

david-watsky-headshot
david-watsky-headshot
David Watsky Senior Editor / Home and Kitchen
David lives in Brooklyn where he's spent more than a decade covering all things edible, including meal kit services, food subscriptions, kitchen tools and cooking tips. Since earning a BA in English from Northeastern in Boston, he's toiled in nearly every aspect of the food business, including as a line cook in Rhode Island where he once made a steak sandwich for Lamar Odom. Right now, he's likely somewhere stress-testing a blender or researching the best way to make bacon. Anything with sesame is his all-time favorite food this week.
Expertise Kitchen tools, appliances, food science, subscriptions and meal kits.
David Watsky
4 min read
$129 at Goldbelly
v-day-dinner
Heart-shaped Valentine's steak dinner for two
$143 at Goldbelly
hancock-lobster-pot-pie-goldbelly
Hancock Gourmet lobster pot pies
$99 at Goldbelly
screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-33-09-pm.png
Mushroom lasagna from Gramercy Tavern
$54 at Goldbelly
screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-37-26-pm.png
Valentine's Day bagels
$49 at Goldbelly
screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-39-57-pm.png
Valentine's Day cookie box
$55 at Goldbelly
goldbelly-cookie-do-edible-cookie-dough
Cookie DO bestseller edible cookie dough four-pack
$65 at Goldbelly
banana-puddin
Magnolia Bakery world-famous banana pudding
$39 at Goldbelly
elles-belles-mini-heart-sugar-cookies-goldbelly
Elle's Belles Bakery Ombre sugar cookies
$109 at Goldbelly
valentine-rise-krispie-treats-goldbelly
Treat House Sooo Much Love! Valentine's deluxe Rice Krispies treats box

Valentine's Day should be an indulgence marathon. Even if you don't celebrate the greeting card holiday, take it upon yourself to get in on the sweetness this February. If you're avoiding restaurants and their bloated tasting menus, but also not interested in cooking a meal from scratch, Goldbelly has a lineup of Valentine's Day-ready eats and sweets that'll make for a delicious and hassle-free day. These include chocolate chip cookie boxes, dark chocolate, candy, and more edible arrangements.

And if you're thinking it's a strange idea to order cakes and steaks online, know that Goldbelly has packing and sending gourmet food down to a science. I've ordered more desserts than I'd care to share and full barbecue dinners from Goldbelly. They always arrive in excellent shape with meticulous instructions on how to heat or serve them. 

From heart-shaped steak dinners and DIY sushi (some cooking required) to cookies, cakes, bagels and bread pudding, these are the 11 best Valentine's Day eats to order on Goldbelly this year. 

Read more: Best flower delivery services for Valentine's Day

v-day-dinner
Goldbelly

This is as impossible a year as ever to bag a Valentine's Day reservation. And even if you could, you may not want to. Score this heart-inspired steak dinner for two from Chesapeake Gay Gourmet instead and bring the romance home. In this V-Day dinner bundle, you'll get two USDA prime heart-shaped filet mignons, a pair of gluten-free Maryland crab cakes and fluffy red velvet cake for dessert. 

If you're worried about cooking a filet, don't be. Just get a cast-iron skillet or regular frying pan scorching hot, cook it a few minutes on each side and finish with some melted butter over the top. Done. 

doras-heart-shaped-ravioli-7d59c4b10d5b05685d5e9a9b226d66ad
Goldbelly

I Trulli is truly one of New York's most beloved Italian eateries, and for Valentine's Day you can order its signature heart-shaped ravioli. These festive beauties are handmade, stuffed with Italian ricotta and striped with beet puree.

hancock-lobster-pot-pie-goldbelly
Goldbelly

For the sweetheart with a savory tooth (not to mention expensive taste), this foursome of decadent little lobster pot pies is perfect. Crowned with puff pastry and decorations, they're an ideal centerpiece for a romantic dinner at home.

screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-33-09-pm.png
Goldbelly

Gramercy Tavern in New York has a few signature dishes, but the mushroom lasagna is right up there with the best of them. For a plant-based dinner, you can have the creamy, earthy pasta treat sent to your door to be defrosted, warmed and eaten on Valentine's Day.

It feeds four but if there are only two of you, you'll be glad to have the leftovers waiting for you on Feb. 15.

screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-53-06-pm.png
Goldbelly

I tried a DIY sushi kit recently and it was surprisingly easy and tons of fun. Oh, and the sushi came out fantastic (*pats self on back*). This kit from the iconic Blue Ribbon sushi joint in NYC has everything you need to whip up four to five rolls plus two sheets of crispy rice.

screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-37-26-pm.png
Goldbelly

Valentine's Day breakfast always gets left out of the fun. Not so with these red and pink heart-shaped bagels from The Bagel Nook. Bag a dozen for $54 on Goldbelly and freeze whatever you don't eat right away.

screen-shot-2022-01-25-at-2-39-57-pm.png
Goldbelly

If you're not the cake type, this assortment of Valentine's Day cookies should soothe your sweet tooth. Flavors include caramel-pretzel chocolate chunk, chocolate-covered strawberry and chocolate fleur de sel.

goldbelly-cookie-do-edible-cookie-dough
Goldbelly

You can safely enjoy this edible cookie dough straight from the fridge -- or bake it if you want to. Build your own dream team of four different flavors, or pick this combo pack of Cookie DO Confections' best-selling flavors, including Cake Batter and Brookie Dough.

banana-puddin
Goldbelly

Made famous for its cupcakes by Sex and the City, Magnolia Bakery is also justly renowned for its luscious banana pudding (which got its due on Broad City). This Goldbelly pack includes six tubs of the world-famous pudding -- enough to make 10 people very happy or one person very happy 10 times.

elles-belles-mini-heart-sugar-cookies-goldbelly
Goldbelly

Looking for something a little more thematic? These adorably petite, heart-shaped vanilla-almond sugar cookies from Montana bakery Elle's Belles are topped with cream cheese frosting in white, pink and red, with sugar sparkles for the perfect finishing touch.

valentine-rise-krispie-treats-goldbelly
Goldbelly

Who doesn't love a Rice Krispie treat? These little babies from Treat House are the perfect bite size so that your honey can savor them all or share them with you. For Valentine's Day, the brand has even created a super sampler, which includes 24 Valentine's-themed Rice Krispie treats, two strawberry shortcake bars and three Valentine's Rice Krispie doughnuts.

This story was originally written by Brittany Loggins and has been updated by David Watsky.