CNET también está disponible en español.

Ir a español

Don't show this again

Services

The GPL: By communists, for communists

A News.com reader writes that he's all for open source done the right way, but the GPL does not fall under that category.

     

      
    The GPL: By communists, for communists

    In response to the May 7 Perspectives column by Michael A. Olson, "A business case for open source":

    Olson is clearly a smart guy, especially because he did not choose to build a business on top of the GPL. I don't have a problem with the Berkeley license, or the Apache license, or the Perl Artistic license, or the MIT license or probably many others.

    But the GPL is ridiculous. Let's say that I am building an application and I want to embed some GPL code. And maybe now I want to modify it because either I find a bug or I want to add an extension. Great--because I have the source code. The only problem is that now when I compile this code into my application, my application is also GPL code. That means I need to publish my proprietary secrets. How can you build a sustainable, competitive advantage when you publish your technology?

    I'm all for open source done the right way, but the GPL is written by communists for other communists. It will kill innovation in the software industry if it catches on. Fortunately, most companies, like Olson's, are smarter than that.

    Bill Brougher
    San Francisco

     

     

        
    Latest Headlines
    display on desktop
    Microsoft issues Messenger patch
    Intel to test Pentium 4s at China plant
    HP holds on to some Evo systems
    Intel says flash memory will thrive
    Caldera cuts projections; CTO resigns
    Cell phone glut spells cheaper handsets
    Oracle goes on the defensive
    BlackBerry maker struggling to blossom
    IBM brings grid computing to games
    Judge denies dismissal bid in DMCA case
    Campaign funds returned in Oracle probe
    Growth seen for online photo services
    Wall Street talks up HP
    NetWorld+Interop: Making connections
    Web site to put gov't rules under one roof
    Pixar's "Monster" payoff continues
    Terra open to Net access deals in U.S.
    Chambers' "show me" tech economy
    Consumers fight AT&T-Comcast merger
    This week's headlines