Via and National Semiconductor today announced that the two companies have signed an agreement under which National will manufacture chipsets designed by Via, including the controversial chipsets that will support faster 133-MHz memory and contain a 133-MHz system bus. Via sources said the chipsets will contain the logo of both companies.
Arcane as all this might appear at first glance, the arrangement could have significant implications. First, the deal could neutralize a lawsuit filed by Intel against Via filed this month that likely would have blocked Via's chipsets from coming to market. Unlike Via, National has an extensive cross-license agreement with Intel, which Via can now take advantage of. Large companies like this often enter into these agreements to ensure that their patents don't conflict.
Second, the agreement could pave the way for the faster, yet relatively cheap, 133-MHz memory to be sold.
Third, the seemingly harmless dual-logo provision is the icing on the cake. It seems to reopen a legal loophole that has allowed companies such as National's Cyrix division, which it sold to Via last week, to make products that compete against Intel's without the threat of legal liability.
"It really does push the limit," said Rich Belgard, an independent patent consultant. "But I think having a dual logo solves any problems."
From a product standpoint, the most tangible effect will likely be the release of the next generation of Intel-compatible chipsets from Via. PC makers, motherboard manufacturers, and memory companies have been eager to adopt Via's Intel compatible chipsets so that they could graduate from memory running at 100 MHz, today's standard, to 133 MHz. This type of technology is becoming more important to the ever-increasing speed of computers.
"The memory guys all have the product in the pipeline. Every PC manufacturer in the world has 133-MHz devices," said Dean Hays, director of marketing for Via. The only thing preventing adoption now, he added, is logistics.
Intel does not have official plans for this faster memory, only the more expensive, and somewhat controversial, Rambus variety. "Because of the price premium and availability, Rambus is not going to be in the mainstream part of the market, at least not this year," said Michael Slater, principal analyst at MicroDesign Resources.
Earlier this month, Intel revoked a technology licensing agreement with Via and filed an action in federal court for patent infringement, moves that effectively killed Via's efforts. National does not have this problem. National's extensive cross-license agreement with Intel puts Via's products back in action and gives manufacturers a way around adopting Rambus memory, for now.
Intel is likely currently reviewing its chipset road map to accommodate 133-MHz SDRAM, Slater added. In the meantime, Via at least will be able to release a solution. "Via is a major chipset vendor," he said.
The "fab" exception
On the legal front, the deal also appears to provide greater insulation to Via customers, according to Belgard. Under current law, a chip manufacturer can make an Intel-compatible processor if it either has a license from Intel or if it consigns to have its chips made in a fabrication facility that has a license with Intel.
This important "fab" exception came out, ironically, in a lawsuit between Cyrix and Intel. National's cross-license with Intel ordinarily would allow for National to make chipsets, or any other product, for Via under the fab exception, Belgard said.
However, in the most recent renewal of the agreement between National and Intel, the fab exception was deleted, he said. National can make products that take advantage of Intel intellectual property, but not on behalf of other companies after 2000.
Enter the dual logo. By containing the two brands, the chipsets can effectively can be said to be a National product. In the end, Intel might be able to sustain a suit against Via for earlier violations of the revoked licensing deal, but it becomes irrelevant as the Via-National chipsets come to market.
A National spokesman said his company would not market the products. A Via spokesman, however, said the product would contain a National logo. In any event, both companies said that the arrangement insulates them from Intel lawsuits. Intel could not be reached for comment.
Later this year, Via plans to come out with a Celeron clone, though it has yet to pick a manufacturer. Stan Swearingen, general manager of Cyrix has said that the company is developing "bulletproof" methods to avoid suits.
Intel disagrees that Via has found a way round the issue. "It doesn't change anything. They are still in breach of the contract and are still infringing on our intellectual property," said Chuck Mulloy, an Intel spokesman. "We do not believe that National has the right to serve as a foundry for Via or anyone else."
Co-branded chipsets are not covered by the National agreement, he postulated. He did not comment on what would happen if Via licensed its technology to National for National-branded chipsets.