Global execs take on tech and innovation
From the McKinsey Quarterly
Special to CNET News.com
September 20, 2005, 10:00 AM PDT
A recent McKinsey Global Survey of Business Executives suggests that technology executives are more bullish about innovation and automation than are their business counterparts. It also suggests that managing on a global scale and finding skilled people are two of tech executives' biggest challenges.
Our survey polled some 9,300 business and technology leaders around the world on the most important trends affecting the global economy during the next five years, particularly factors that could promote or constrain growth. Overall, business and technology executives see eye to eye: Both identify the increasing pace of technological innovation, the growing affluence of emerging economies and low-cost offshore manufacturing as the most important trends for global business. But opinions diverge when it comes to the importance of innovation and certain key management issues.
The importance of innovation
CIOs must make information technology's business value more visible--and the costs much more controllable--so that IT isn't seen as a black box.
This finding appears to reflect frustration among nontech executives about IT organizations' perceived inability to deliver tangible value to business. Most of the typical IT budget pays for IT operations and maintenance, with only about 10 percent to 20 percent allocated to initiatives that improve overall business performance.
Since business executives tend not to see the overall results and impact of IT spending, chief information officers must make information technology's business value more visible--and the costs much more controllable--so that IT isn't seen as a black box. Some tech executives are addressing these issues by creating standard IT "products" with clear price-performance options for business users and by establishing cost
Technology executives in some regions and industries are more bullish on innovation than are their counterparts elsewhere. In North America, 87 percent of CIOs and CTOs see it as a significant driver of profitability. A smaller proportion of Asian (77 percent) and European (74 percent) executives see a strong link between innovation and profits, perhaps because technological innovation tends to reduce the labor content of work, and labor regulations are tighter in Western Europe and Japan. And there is less pressure in the rest of Asia to optimize labor, since it is relatively cheap in that region.
Fifty-three percent of CIOs and CTOs--compared with 45 percent of business executives--cite the ability to innovate as the most important capability for growth. It is interesting that 33 percent of technology executives see improving their companies' current products as the key driver of growth--a significantly higher proportion than the 19 percent who favor developing new products.
Among business executives, improving current products and developing new ones were rated as the most important way to grow by 25 percent and 22 percent, respectively. What's the reason for these differences? Our hypothesis is that CIOs tend to be less involved with new-product innovation, in part because the traditional IT organization is seen as not moving fast enough to keep up with the iterative new-product innovation cycle. CIOs have an opportunity to support innovation with a faster "try it, do it, fix it" approach, in addition to supporting incremental improvements to existing products.
Operational and managerial challenges
What lies behind this difference? Business leaders clearly have unpleasant memories of large IT-led automation projects, such as enterprise resource planning (ERP), that were long on costs but short on results often because of a failure to address the necessary process changes fully and to develop the necessary skills. It is just as likely, however, that tech executives are biased toward IT-driven projects while business executives are inclined to improve efficiency in other ways, including offshoring to lower-cost locations and driving scale through acquisitions.
CIOs have an opportunity to support innovation with a faster "try it, do it, fix it" approach, in addition to supporting incremental improvements to existing products.
CIOs must take a more integrated view of the sources of business value, addressing not just labor-saving automation but also the optimization of capital through practices such as outsourcing or offshoring. The IT organization as a whole should build stronger change management skills.
All executives consider the cost and availability of talent to be major issues. Tech executives say it's their biggest managerial challenge. A higher proportion (44 percent) of Asian CIOs and CTOs than of their counterparts in North America (26 percent) and Europe (20 percent) rank this concern as a pressing one--no doubt because of growing demand for IT services in China, India and other parts of Asia. Seventy-five percent of tech executives see the cost of talent as the most important constraint on growth, though Asian CIOs and CTOs also see increasingly sophisticated consumers as a major obstacle to it.
After talent, the issue most commonly chosen by tech executives as their biggest challenge was increasing the size and scale of their companies (25 percent); only 19 percent of business executives agreed with them. (CIOs and CTOs in smaller companies saw increasing scale as the biggest challenge overall.) Given the infrastructure challenges (such as managing e-mail across geographies) that IT executives face as their companies grow in size and global reach, this finding is hardly a surprise.
As globalization intensifies, executives responsible for IT must not only manage different standards and tools across countries but also cooperate with human resources and other functions so that companies can handle issues such as security and data access control.
The pace of technological innovation, an increasingly global economy, and the emergence of developing nations such as China and India are transforming the business landscape. Business and technology executives will better prepare themselves to capitalize on the new opportunities these changes present if they work closely together and leverage their different perspectives.
For more insight, go to the McKinsey Quarterly Web site.
Copyright © 1992-2005 McKinsey & Company, Inc.
Interested in more research studies like these? If so, free registration at The McKinsey Quarterly will offer you topical alerts, access to selected full-text articles, and more. Premium membership offers full access to the McKinsey Quarterly site, including archives, and the print edition.
To browse additional Quarterly articles, click on one of the following topics: