CNET también está disponible en español.

Ir a español

Don't show this again

Phones

CNET readers blast 'lazy, greedy' iPhone 5S and 5C

We asked the CNET UK audience for their thoughts on the Apple iPhone 5S and 5C -- and they did not hold back...

The new iPhone 5S and 5C are here, and these colourful phones are prompting some colourful language. We asked you, the faithful CNET audience, for your thoughts -- and you did not hold back, telling us what you think of Apple's latest smart phones in no uncertain terms.

"The new iPhone 5S demonstrates what Apple are about, a luxury phone with a beautiful design and USEFUL innovations, such as Touch ID," gushes George Davis. "Samsung waste their time with air gestures and other gimmicks that no one will ever use, and put it into an oversized cheap package. iPhone all the way."

"Quietly impressed," says Adam Gates. "I'll be getting a 5S."

And that, dear reader, is it for the positive comments. Out of 150 replies to our informal Facebook poll, the overwhelming majority of you were, how can I put it? Underwhelmed.

"A step backward" 

"Nothing spectacular in terms of hardware," says Andrew Dart. "Wrong screen size for 2013," says Benjamin Bradshaw. "My 7-year-old laptop has a fingerprint reader," points out Eamonn Gibson. "Poserphone," says Airship Charlie Lee-Gee.

"The new iPhones are a step backwards for Apple, still can't match the Galaxy S4 or HTC One and with the Google Nexus 5 due out soon they'll be pushed further down the pecking order," says Crispin Norman.

"Can't wait for the day the fingerprint scanner fails and people can't get into their locked phones due to a glitch. It's coming... You heard it here first!" LOLs Damian Brierley.

"The thought of going back to iPhone gives me a headache," says Chris Blackman, massaging his temples. "Nexus 4 is the dream phone and its £400 cheaper. Jokers."

"The brand of mugs" 

Ah yes, the price. "So the 'budget' iPhone is more than double the price of a Nexus 4... they can keep it," says Gary Sutherland. "Apple is getting lazy and is still being greedy. 5C should have been much cheaper," says Aliya Gulam.

"I prefer Android but it's horses for courses y'know?" says Mark Upcraft, taking a balanced view. "I think people demonising Apple for the (frankly ludicrous) pricing of the 5C need to take a long hard look at the Samsung Galaxy S3/4.

"However I strongly believe that the price of a 4-inch plastic phone cannot be justified and further shows that Apple are completely out of touch with the world outside of California if they consider £470 to be 'budget'."

"Apple are the brand of mugs," says Christopher Harvey. "Nothing special but we will charge you much as we can."

Most damningly of all, "iPhones are phones for parents these days," says Dave Blackwell.

Note-worthy alternatives 

So all round not a great day for Apple. "I'd go for the Note 3," says Daniel Bree, and he's not the only one -- aside from a few mentions of Windows Phone, Samsung's oversized phablet is the iPhone alternative that cropped up the most in our poll.

The last word goes to a forward-thinking Mario Da Mata: "Wait for iPhone 6…" Same time next year then Mario!

What do you think of the new iPhones? Tell me your thoughts in the comments or keep the opinions coming on our Facebook wall.