Apple's efforts to trademark an icon for its iOS music player in the U.S. have been denied due to design from a company that no longer exists.
As part of a decision handed down by the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board last week, the group found Apple's icon a bit too similar to one issued to iLike in 2008, upholding an initial finding from a trademark examiner.
iLike, of course, no longer exists. The company wasin late 2009 and was eventually absorbed into the company's own music product.
"In comparing the marks within the above-noted legal parameters, the marks at issue are similar because they comprise a double musical note in an orange rectangle," the decision, picked up by GigaOm today, reads.
The group adds that the similarities "outweigh any specific differences" when the two icons are put side-by-side:
Apple applied for the trademarked icon in April 2010, right around the time it began using it as the music player icon on the iPod Touch. The company would later bring it over to the iPhone and iPad as part of iOS 5.
The decision can be appealed by Apple, which spent a considerable part of last month arguing
Apple - USE TAG
reading•Apple loses bid for music app icon trademark
Oct 21•OnePlus 6T: Every detail and rumor so far
Oct 21•iPhone XR hands-on: Colorful phones make a great first impression
Oct 21•The Apple Watch Series 4 -- down to the tiniest detail
Oct 21•The MateBook X Pro squeezes some big features into its little package