CNET también está disponible en español.

Ir a español

Don't show this again


A case against Trusted Senders

A reader writes that the Internet does not need Trusted Senders--it needs for there to be no unsolicited e-mail.


    A case against Trusted Senders

    In response to the June 25 Perspectives column by Fran Meier, "Hitting spam below the belt":

    Meier may be sincere, but so are many spammers. She is--as they are--convinced of the worth of what they do.

    Before commercialization, the Internet did not need "Trusted Senders." Pretty much everyone was a Trusted Sender; there was hardly an issue. Almost anyone could have forged the e-mail sender; almost nobody did. It was an environment of cooperation and trust. The Internet does not need Trusted Senders--it needs for there to be no unsolicited e-mail.

    If someone wants or accepts commercial e-mail from a vendor, that person has little reason to question the e-mail. Creating this strange concept of Trusted Sender and then grafting that on to e-mail is not a solution. It is a means of permanently commercializing what is and should be a private channel of communication. The only virtue I can see to Trusted Sender is that it would be a quick and easy thing to detect with one's anti-spam filters so that the message could be deleted. Beyond that it is a distraction that obscures both the problem of spam and the true solutions to that problem.

    Most of the solutions will be for businesses to act intelligently and to respect customers and potential customers by not barraging them with unwanted e-mail messages. If businesses don't do this, customers will create ways to deflect the spam.

    I write this with legitimate businesses in mind. The low-end spammers will never appreciate the need to respect customers. They will have to be forced out of operation by whatever combination of filtering and legislation is needed to end their reign of abuse.

    Brad Spencer
    Madison, Wis.



    Latest Headlines
    display on desktop
    Messier keeps his seat at Vivendi
    Web previews second "Rings" film
    Chipmaker gets into video compression
    Sun buys start-up to boost UltraSparc
    Palm reports loss, names hardware CEO
    Profit woes weigh on markets
    Gadgets bring the office on vacation
    HP gears up post-merger PCs vows to undersell Amazon books
    Is that Wi-Fi on your sleeve?
    Commentary: Loudcloud's sensible move
    Teen sued over fake story posted online
    Lindows--low cost, but a changed tune
    eBay assigns new duties to execs
    Decision on KPNQwest buyer nears
    Calif. panel pushes software tax reform
    Peregrine Systems names new CFO
    IT pros: U.S. government at cyber risk
    Ciena looks to win big telecom carriers
    This week's headlines