This content is rated TV-MA, and is for viewers 18 years or older. Are you of age?
Sorry, you are not old enough to view this content.
CNET Update: The ethical problem with Facebook's emotional experiment
About Video Comments (0 ) Transcript

CNET Update: The ethical problem with Facebook's emotional experiment

2:59 /

Facebook teamed up with academia to manipulate users' emotions in a week-long science experiment, but users had no idea they were test subjects. CNET's Bridget Carey explains Facebook's latest controversy.

Life is just one big experiment called Facebook. I'm Bridget Carey, and this is your CNet update. [MUSIC] The world has yet another reason to distrust Facebook. More than 680,000 Facebook users have been subjected to a psychological experiment. And it was done, without the knowledge of the participants. The network set out to see if it could manipulate user's emotions, and it worked with Academia, to conduct a week long test, back in January of 2012. Those chosen for the experiment either saw only positive posts in their feed, or they only saw posts with negative words. The study showed that if you saw mostly happy words, you were a little more positive in what you shared in your status update. And you're slightly more negative, when you're subjected to a week of doom and gloom. Now, we learned of this because the study was published in a science journal. And adding to the ethical problems, the study was funded by the government. Facebook was toying with people's mental health. But why? To learn if advertisements could take advantage of our moods? If you aren't posting much, well Facebook cranked up the kittens to get you happy again. With any study, the typical ethical practice is to get informed consent from your subjects, so people know they're part of an experiment. Facebook says it was fair game to test us because of one word, hidden deep in the data use policy. You know, that document that none of us read. It states that your information may be used for internal operations and research. When I think of research in that context, I think of Facebook wanting to study where I click, not that I want Facebook to use me as a lab rat to see if it can make me sad. I wouldn't be surprised if an organization, perhaps the Federal Trade Commission, goes after Facebook for not being clear over how this research data was being used. But going forward, if enough people speak out and complain, or shy away from using Facebook, well then, it could take a hint, and it might be more transparent about future experiments. The network is on shaky ground as it is now with public trust. And even if you don't care to be tested on, you should care about this. Because Facebook is collecting health information. Facebook owns the fitness tracking app called Moves, and as fitness tracking bands and smart watches grow in popularity, we have to wonder, what sort of health information will Facebook have on us, and can we trust what it does with that data? Well let's switch gears to Google's social network. No, not Google Plus, not that Buzz thing. I mean Google's first social network. It's called Orkut, and after ten years, Google is shutting it down. Orkut was really big in Brazil and India, but it'll close on September 30th. Google says it rather focus it's energy on YouTube, Blogger, and Google Plus. That's your tech news update. You can always get more details on these stories, at cnet.com. From our studios in New York, I'm Bridget Carey. [MUSIC]

New releases

Reasons not to buy an Apple Wa...
3:12 September 12, 2014
The Apple Watch is a tempting wearable, but there are many reasons to stay away.
Play video
Science and art team up to create...
5:17 September 12, 2014
This week on Crave we check out a light-​based Rube Goldberg machine complete with melting ice, Godzilla gets...
Play video
2015 Chrysler 200C: A dud no longer...
21:41 September 12, 2014
The lowly Chrysler 200, reinvented; which state has the fastest drivers; and how to get TV in your car.
Play video
Apple's free album has some folks...
2:56 September 12, 2014
High traffic causes iPhone 6 preorder problems, a free U2 album leads to confusion, and SanDisk breaks a record...
Play video
The 404 Show 1,551: Batman ruined?...
33:37 September 12, 2014
There's some new Batman controversy about the size of his Batmobile cannon. Plus, we'll learn how to live...
Play video
Take a look at the luxurious, metal...
1:59 September 12, 2014
Hit play on our video review of the Samsung Galaxy Alpha to see what we think of Samsung's first use of luxurious...
Play video
Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini flaunts...
1:41 September 12, 2014
The Samsung Galaxy S5 Mini has a near identical design to the flagship S5, but comes in a much more comfortable...
Play video
Dell's Inspiron 14 5000 a good...
1:52 September 12, 2014
Like all of the Inspiron laptops we've tested, the 14-inch 5000 series is a good value with excellent battery...
Play video