6
This content is rated TV-MA, and is for viewers 18 years or older. Are you of age?
Sorry, you are not old enough to view this content.

Prizefight: Motorola Atrix 4G vs. Samsung Galaxy S 4G

About Video Transcript

Prizefight: Motorola Atrix 4G vs. Samsung Galaxy S 4G

5:22 /

It's a throw down showdown between two of the hottest 4G feature rich phones on the market. Will the Atrix 4G's versatility be able to top the Galaxy S 4G's media rich services? Let's get it on to find out!

-What's up, Prizefight fans? I'm Brian Tong and this week, it's a 4G face off between two feature-rich phones. It's a Prizefight punch out between the Motorola Atrix 4G on AT&T and the Samsung Galaxy S 4G on T-Mobile. Our judges for this fight are: Senior Editor Bonnie "The Boom" Cha; Senior Editor Kent "I'm Actually" German; and you know who, Brian "Ling Long Ting" Tong. Now, we'll take all 3 judges' scores and average them out to the nearest 10th each round. The final Prizefight score will be an average of all rounds using the same decimal system. Let's get this party started. First round is design. Both phones have adopted an iPhone-nesque exterior, and it works. Motorala's Atrix 4G is a real clean and smooth design with its high resolution, sharp qHD display. There's a nice weight to it, but an awkward power button on the top of its back side. Now, Samsung's Galaxy S 4G is a sharp and sleek design with a silver matte finish. From the front, this looks like an iPhone. It's slightly longer and wider to hold, and it's lighter in weight. Its AMOLED screen looks great but, it's just not as clean as the competition. Motorola's Atrix 4G just gets the edge in the first round with a 4.3, and Samsung's Galaxy S gets a 4. Next round is controls and user interface. Both phones are running Android 2.2, so you could almost call this a draw with its voice commands and turn-by-turn maps, until you get to their custom Android interfaces. Motorola forces you to sign up for a MOTOBLUR account to use the phone. To use the phone! Now, MOTOBLUR has improved and it's less intrusive, but this phone also doesn't include the Swype writing feature. See in my home screen as tiles is cool, but it can't make up for its shortcomings. Samsung brings their TouchWiz interface and it's really simplified the Android experience. Purists will complain it looks too much like iOS, but it retains Android's myriad of features. You'll get Swype functionality, and I'm a big fan of quick access to the services in the notifications drop down. The Galaxy S 4G gets a perfect 5, and the Atrix 4G gets a 4. So, after averaging 2 rounds, the Galaxy S leads by 3/10 of a point. Round 3 is features. The Atrix 4G instantly shows off with its dual-core processor that makes for a snappier experience. There's 16 gigs of on-board storage with an SD card slot for up to 32 gigs more. It has an HDMI port for video out, and even if you won't use them, it's compatible with its laptop dock, a stand alone mouse and keyboard, and a media dock. This guy is a jack of all trades. Now, the Samsung Galaxy S 4G is no chump with a 1 gigahertz processor that still feels pretty speedy. It has only 185 megs of on-board storage with a card slot that supports up to 32 gigs more. Both phones support Wi-Fi hotspot capabilities, but the Atrix is one of the most versatile phones we've ever seen, and it takes this round with a perfect 5 of its own, and Samsung gets a 4. Round 4 is Web browsing and multimedia. The Web browsers are pretty much a push here, and many Android users are using other browsers anyways. The Atrix 4G's higher resolution screen makes for a more enjoyable Web experience, but we were all let down by its slower data speeds that AT&T locked down for the time being without telling customers. Now, it brings a 5-megapixel camera with a dual LED flash that will support up to 1080p video capture, and its media player is the standard Android one, so there's nothing really to be impressed by there. The Galaxy S 4G has the same Web browser features, but I do like its more visual multiple browser windows, and its data speeds were excellent. It features a 5-megapixel camera with 720p video support, a variety of settings within the camera app, and it delivers better image quality compared to the Atrix 4G. Plus, it comes with an ecosystem with its media hub ready to deliver movies and TV shows directly to the device. The Galaxy S 4G takes this round with a 4.7, and the Atrix 4G gets a 3.7. So, after averaging 4 rounds, Samsung leads by just 1/10 of a point. The final round that decides its all is call quality and performance. The Atrix brings solid call quality on both sides. Bonnie found a few garbles, but its dual-core processing makes a difference, and it was able to squeeze up to 10 hours of talk time in our test. Plus, you could feel the speed and fast don't lie. Now the Galaxy S had excellent call quality that was cleaner compared to the Atrix 4G. Our labs were able to crank out 9 hours of talk time, but we did come across a few moments where it had some slight performance lag. It's too close to call, and the judges are calling this round a tie at 4 points a piece. So, let's average out all 5 rounds. And in a battle where both phones won 2 rounds a piece and tied the last, the Samsung Galaxy S 4G just barely, barely edges the Motorola Atrix 4G, 4.3 to 4.2, and is your Prizefight winner. With a cat fight this close, you can't go wrong with either phone, but it's the Galaxy S 4G's interface, Web browsing, and multimedia that prove to be the difference makers today. I'm Bring Tong. Thanks for watching and we'll catch you guys next time on another Prizefight.

New releases

Samsung's Z1 phone runs Tizen, not Android, to achieve low price
1:58 March 4, 2015
Come take a look at the Samsung Z1, a 4-inch phone that runs Tizen software, not Android in order to make it affordable for developing...
Play video
Porsche 911 GT3 RS: The number of the beast
4:51 March 4, 2015
More power, less weight, harder dynamics. The 911's angry sibling has arrived and it's out for victory. XCAR checks out the new GT3...
Play video
Comparison shopping for baby gear
0:59 March 4, 2015
Whether you're an expectant parent, new parent or just trying to purchase a baby gift for a friend, wading through the thousands of...
Play video
The McLaren 675LT is simply devilish
1:30 March 4, 2015
The McLaren 675LT builds upon the McLaren 650 with better aerodynamics, less weight and a diabolical 666 horsepower.
Play video
Better than Touch ID? Check out Vkansee's optical fingerprint scanner
1:13 March 3, 2015
Clean or dirty, wet or dry, this highly tuned fingerprint scanner promises to outdo Apple's ho-hum tech with a far higher resoluti...
Play video
Koenigsegg Regera
1:27 March 3, 2015
Swedish supercar maker Koenigsegg rolled out the Regera at the 2015 Geneva auto show -- and it just might be the most powerful plug-in...
Play video
Nvidia Shield
2:59 March 3, 2015
The Nvidia Shield offers gamers an affordable, high-performance set-top box that combines the best of Android TV and Nvidia's own GRID...
Play video
Tomorrow Daily 138: Learning to cook with VR, a robotic bear caregiver and more
24:12 March 3, 2015
On today's show, we take a look at the world's first 3D-printed jet engines, discuss an app that helps you learn to cook via virtual...
Play video