Which phone emits the most radiation?

Is your favourite phone melting your mind or causing cancer? No, it's not, but we look at the radiation levels of some of the top phones in the UK to put your mind at rest.

Is your favourite phone melting your mind or giving you cancer? According to the latest research, almost certainly not . For your peace of mind though, we looked at the radiation levels of some of the top phones in the UK and ranked them accordingly.

In order to monitor the levels of radiation we're exposed to, the government requests that all phones are tested to determine their specific absorption rate (SAR) value. The figure represents how much radiation is absorbed by the body's tissue, in Watts per kilogram (W/kg). The higher the number, the more radiation absorbed.

As inert as a well-washed pebble, and with the lowest score of our phones is the popular Samsung Galaxy S 2, with HTC's Sensation only just behind at 0.358 W/kg.

HTC's Incredible scored 0.876W/kg, outdoing the iPhone 4, which notched a relatively high rating of 1.14W/kg.

Bottom of the heap was the Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro. Owners of the phone receive a tall serving of 1.61W/kg -- the highest of all the phones we've reviewed this year. This is followed very closely by the Acer beTouch E210 with 1.6W/kg.

Using a mobile poses an unknown risk of causing cancer , according to the World Health Organisation. Mobile phone use is classed as a 2B carcinogen, which sounds scary until you find out that doing carpentry or drinking coffee presents an equal risk. Basically, it might do you some harm over a long period, but no one has produced any definitive proof either way.

The max level permitted within Europe is 2.0W/kg, and the phones we've reviewed this year didn't come anywhere near that figure, so we don't think you have anything to worry about whatever phone you choose. We've listed the maximum SAR levels for each phone below. The coolest are at the top, the hottest at the bottom.

Manufacturers tend to list their phones' SAR ratings on their websites (here are the sites for Nokia, Sony Ericsson, Samsung and Motorola). When we couldn't find it on the company site we scoured the Internet for another source.

The results below are colour-coded. The SAR levels in green are from the phone manufacturers' websites, while red results are from comparison websites that list all of the phones' specs that appear on their packaging, but should be considered unofficial.

We've also included two US ratings in the table, where a European result wasn't available. Although Americans use a different radiation testing method, the results aren't incredibly dissimilar. They test phones for SAR at both head and waist height, whereas here in Europe we just test the phone at head height.

So you should take the red and US results with a pinch of salt -- they aren't the official European SAR level, so the actual rating may vary slightly.

 Phone model:
 SAR level (Watts per kg):
Samsung Galaxy S 2
 0.338
Huawei Ideos X5
 0.340
HTC Desire S  0.353
HTC Sensation
 0.358
Sony Ericsson Xperia Play
 0.360
Google Nexus S  0.395
Motorola Gleam  0.405
HTC 7 Pro  0.418
HTC Salsa  0.489
LG Optimus 3D
 0.550
Nokia E7
 0.560
INQ Cloud Touch
 0.597
Acer Liquid Metal
 0.622
Samsung Wave 2  0.988
HP Pre 3
 0.640
Sony Ericsson Xperia Arc
 0.660
Samsung Solid Immerse
 0.665
Samsung Galaxy Fit  0.718
Acer Liquid Mini
 0.719
Samsung Galaxy Gio
 0.790
HTC ChaCha  0.822
HTC Desire HD  0.826
Samsung Galaxy Ace
 0.840
Motorola Atrix  0.840
HTC Incredible S
 0.876
HTC Wildfire S 0.899
Blackberry Torch 9800
 0.910
Samsung Galaxy Mini
 0.961
Samsung Wave 578  0.988
LG Optimus 2x
 1.060
LG A140
 1.080
iPhone 3GS
 1.10
Sony Ericsson Xperia Neo
 1.10
Nokia C1-02
 1.130
Blackberry Bold 9780
 1.150
Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini 1.170
iPhone 4
 1.170
T-Mobile Zest  1.090
Nokia C2-01
 1.20
LG GS101
 1.20
Nokia C5-03
 1.290
LG Optimus Black
 1.30
ZTE Skate
 1.350
HP Veer
 1.380
Dell Venue Pro
 1.390
Viewsonic ViewPad 4
 1.390
HTC Gratia
 1.540
Acer beTouch E210
 1.60
Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro
 1.610
Acer Iconia Smart
 Unknown or unreleased
LG Optimus Chat
 Unknown or unreleased
Viewsonic 350
 Unknown or unreleased
Sony Ericsson Xperia Pro
 Unknown or unreleased
 

Update: We've added several more phones to the list in response to reader requests. We previously published the values for the Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini and Mini pro under the wrong names; this has been corrected.

 

Join the discussion

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Don't Miss
Hot Products
Trending on CNET

Last-minute gift ideas

Under pressure? These will deliver on time

With plenty of top-notch retailers offering digital gifts, you still have time to salvage your gift-giving reputation.