Judge dismisses Apple vs Motorola patent case

An irritated judge has thrown out the Apple vs Motorola patent case, saying neither has a valid argument.

An irritated judge has thrown out the Apple vs Motorola patent case, saying neither company "can establish a right to relief", The Verge reports. He basically thinks that neither Motorola nor Apple has a valid case.

Judge Richard Posner is the man getting frustrated with both companies, and considering all the accusations they keep flinging at each other, who can blame him? Posner warned Apple's lawyers about filing too many motions last month, so it's not like he's willing to take any nonsense from the company.

And what reason did he give for dismissing the case? He says neither company can prove exactly how much money the alleged patent infringements have cost them, which is quite a good point. Both companies are asking for financial compensation, so Posner says blocking products from going on sale would be pointless.

He's issued a temporary order for now, but might change his mind when he reaches a final decision, which should be sometime next week, and there is a chance, albeit slight, that he'll let the case run.

Motorola issued a very positive statement on the ruling: "We are pleased by the Illinois trial court's tentative ruling today dismissing Apple's patent claims and look forward to receiving the full decision."

Apple and Motorola have been embroiled in patent disputes on both sides of the Atlantic, with Moto even succeeding in having some Apple devices banned from sale in Germany (though the decision was overturned pretty quickly). Apple won the slide-to-unlock patent dispute though, with Motorola being found guilty of infringing it with its own version, though not on the Xoom .

Posner also refused to bar the late Steve Jobs' quotes about Google from being referenced in the case (seeing as Google now owns Motorola ).

Was the judge right? Or does each company have a legitimate case? Let me know your thoughts in the comments, or on our Facebook page.

About the author

    Joe has been writing about consumer tech for nearly seven years now, but his liking for all things shiny goes back to the Gameboy he received aged eight (and that he still plays on at family gatherings, much to the annoyance of his parents). His pride and joy is an Infocus projector, whose 80-inch picture elevates movie nights to a whole new level.


    Discuss Judge dismisses Apple vs Motorola patent...

    Conversation powered by Livefyre

    This week on CNET News
    Hot Products
    Trending on CNET

    CNET Forums

    Looking for tech help?

    Whether you’re looking for dependable tech advice or offering helpful tricks, join the conversation in our forums.