Ad agencies: We'd rather work with Google than Apple

In what many might view as a remarkable reversal of fortune, a survey of senior advertising figures shows their enthusiasm for working with Apple is fading a little.

Ad agencies now vote Google? Apple/YouTube Screenshot by Chris Matyszczyk/CNET

Apple used to own glamor.

Everyone stared and admired and wished they could be as clever and beautiful.

Indeed, many is the meeting I've sat in where ad agency execs used Apple as its primary example of everything from brand love to the genius of simplicity.

Something, though, has become twisted of late. No, not with ad execs -- they still slavishly follow trends in the hope of bathing in their reflected glory.

Rather, Apple is straining to maintain its veneer of indisputable sexiness.

This suspicion seems to have finally leaked through to ad agencies. In the latest survey performed by executive search company the Talent Business, senior agency figures now crave to work with Google, rather than Apple.

Even three years ago, this would have been more sacrilegious than an agency exec paying for his own lunch.

Now, however, Google comes second only to Nike in the list of most desired clients. As Ad Age reports, Apple slipped from second to fifth.

Apple's advertising has been wayward for some time. It's been partly hamstrung by a lack of new products to advertise. However, the recent attempts to offer high-falutin' philosophy have enjoyed all the fine writing of a corporate manual.

Its "Designed by Apple in California" ad offers limping attempts at lyricism, such as: "This is what matters; the experience of a product."

Google, on the other hand, made some of the best ads of 2012 -- especially the brilliant Chrome ad "Jess Time."

Even in launching the ultimate in nerd narcissism, Google Glass, the company has been very clever in trying to humanize the inhuman .

It may well be that on September 10, Apple will create a vibrant revitalization by presenting the unexpected.

Currently, though, it sits not only behind Nike (often the agencies' favorite), but also Google, Volkswagen, and Adidas as the brand agencies most want to work with.

And it's heading in the wrong direction.

 

Join the discussion

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Don't Miss
Hot Products
Trending on CNET

Last-minute gift ideas

Under pressure? These will deliver on time

With plenty of top-notch retailers offering digital gifts, you still have time to salvage your gift-giving reputation.