WD Black 2 Dual Drive review: Capacious and affordable SSD-based storage

The WD Black 2 installation software will unlock the HDD portion of the WD Black 2 Dual Drive and format it into a new partition for the user.
The WD Black 2 installation software will unlock the HDD portion of the WD Black 2 Dual Drive and format it into a new partition for the user. Dong Ngo/CNET

Two-step installation, no RAID support
Out of the box, when plugged into a computer only the Black 2's SSD drive is recognized, and it looks as though it's a 120GB SSD. You can install Windows on this drive (the Black 2 only works with Windows for now, but Mac support is coming soon), or clone an existing system onto it. In the latter case, you'll find the included USB-to-SATA transfer cable and Acronis drive clone and backup software very helpful; just make sure the system's old drive has less than 120GB of data on it. (If you need help cloning your system check out this how-to post. )

Once your computer is up and running with the 120GB portion hosting the operating system, you need to install the Black 2 installer software, which reveals the 1TB HDD and formats it into a separate partition. Now, after a restart, your system has two drives, with the OS and applications residing on the SSD and the HDD being the secondary drive for extra storage space.

Note that the installer software's only job is to unlock and format the HDD portion. After that you can safely remove it from your computer, and if you don't, it doesn't run each time your computer starts. I believe WD purposefully locked the 1TB hard drive out of the box so you won't mistakenly install an operating system on it -- the SSD is supposed to host the OS and programs to offer the best performance.

As you might imagine from this two-step setup, the Black 2 Dual Drive is not designed to be used in RAID configurations.

The drive comes in a retail package that includes a handy USB 3.0-to-SATA cable and helpful free downloadable system cloning software.
The drive comes in a retail package that includes a handy USB 3.0-to-SATA cable and helpful free downloadable system cloning software. Dong Ngo/CNET

Cost per gigabyte
At $300 for 1.2TB total, the Black 2 Dual Drive costs 25 cents per gigabyte. Compared with a regular laptop drive, which generally goes for somewhere between 7 cents and 15 cents per gigabyte, the new WD drive is quite expensive. But compared with real SSDs, which cost up to $1 per gigabyte, it's a steal.

At around 11 cents per gigabyte, most SSHDs are more affordable than the Black 2, but none can offer even close to its performance. In all, I find the Black2 Dual Drive competitively priced; you can expect its street price to go even lower.

Performance
If you set up the WD Black 2 Dual Drive correctly, its performance is that of the 120GB SSD; the 1TB HDD is just for storage data and plays no role in the system's performance. Accordingly, in my testing the drive offered the performance of a typical entry-level 120GB SSD.

Compared with a regular hard drive, the Black 2 helped significantly boost the performance of the test machine, making it boot up much faster, taking about 13 seconds. The system also resumed from sleep mode almost instantly and applications launched much faster.

CNET Labs' data transfer scores
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
As Secondary Drive (Read Only)
As Secondary Drive (Write only)
As OS Drive (Read and Write)
OCZ Vector
277.84
286.77
243.01
Seagate 600 SSD
275.21
259.01
192.26
Plextor M5 Pro Xtreme
270.8
269.78
236.18
Transcend SSD720
269.55
230.58
145.26
WD Black 2 Dual Drive
228.2
114.66
174.65
SanDisk Extreme II
203.42
255.86
224.27
OCZ Vector 150
200.46
265.32
231.42
Samsung 840 Evo (Rapid)
193.32
289.32
378.44
Samsung 840 Evo
184.45
266.9
257.13
Seagate Laptop Thin SSHD
84.75
39.61
10.57

In sequential copy tests, the drive offered a sustained speed of some 115MBps for writing, which was the slowest among the SSDs I've reviewed, but much faster compared with regular hard drives. Note that all SSDs I've reviewed were at least 240GB or larger, and, in the world of SSDs, a larger capacity generally means faster performance. In writing, the drive did much better with aq score of 228MBps, though that was still just average on the chart. In tests where it performed both writing and reading at the same time, the drive registered 175MBps, below the average of other SSDs.

In PC Mark 8 benchmark, where the entire system was tested as a whole, the drive performed on par with other SSDs.

PC Mark 8 Scores
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
Storage Score
Work Score
Home Score
Samsung 840 Evo (Rapid)
4990
4605
3324
Samsung 840 Evo
4967
4665
3339
OCZ Vector
4958
4646
3327
OCZ Vector 150
4948
4909
3437
Plextor M5 Pro Xtreme
4948
4658
3331
SanDisk Extreme II
4938
4680
3306
Seagate 600 SSD
4896
4621
3296
WD Black 2 Dual Drive
4869
4935
3439
Transcend SSD720
4779
4658
3328
Seagate Laptop Thin SSHD
2512
4585
3251

Conclusion
Offering the performance of an entry-level SSD, 1.2TB of total storage space, and a $300 price-tag, the WD Black 2 Dual Drive is the most affordable and largest capacity SSD-based storage solution to date. For example, the Samsung 840 Evo, which is one of the least expensive SSDs on the market, cost some $330 for just 500GB, or the recently reviewed OCZ Vector 150, $260 for just 240GB. While the Dual Drive is not a conventional SSD throughout, the difference is minimal thanks to the use of a real and dedicated SSD as the main drive to host the operating system and software.

That said, with a top five-year warranty to back it up, the WD Black 2 Dual Drive deserves one of the top spots on my list of recommendations for replacement internal drives if you have an older computer that still uses a hard drive as its main storage, be it a desktop or laptop. When support for Mac is available, the drive will be like your very own Fusion drive for your older Mac.

Editors' Top PicksSee All

 

Join the discussion

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Quick Specifications See All

  • Form Factor 2.5"
  • Hard Drive Type internal hard drive
  • Capacity 1 TB