Roxio Toast is in an odd position--and has been for years: This giant of Mac disc-creation tools has no competition on the shelves. That is, there's no product around that provides anywhere close to the features it offers--but that's because the audio, video, image, and disc-creation abilities that ship with Macs satisfy the majority of users. But for those who need more, Roxio Toast is clearly the best option.
Considering that the product has no marketplace competition, Toast's developers do a great job of keeping it cutting-edge. This latest version, Toast 8 Titanium (you've just gotta love that silly name) delivers functionality that will surpass the hardware capabilities to which most Mac owners have become accustomed. For example, Toast lets you convert and save TiVoToGo files and burn Blu-ray or LightScribe discs. It also lets users save large files or folders over several discs for either Macs or Windows PCs; create audio discs with crossfades, effects, and transitions; and even recover damaged files. And all this for a reasonable $79.99.
Toast's friendly interface has been modified in this release to make it easier to access the various options, and while it's mostly successful, it also makes the product feel sterile. We'd like to see the interface warmed up a bit, so it feels more like the trusted program we've been using for years.
Gone are the tabs along the top of the screen that let you select which type of disc you'd like to create. Those options have been moved to the left column, where you now first click a disc type, then choose the exact project you'd like to work on. In turn, the left column's previous resident, the Media Browser, has been moved to its own free-floating window, so that you can see disc options at the same time you browse your media. That's a poor change. Having the Media Browser in the left column already made it easy to access, and the new free-floating window always has to be on top, which means you can't click the main window to bring it forward.
If the improvements to version 7 felt a little light to some, version 8 impresses with significant additions. Toast now lets you burn TiVoToGo recordings to a DVD or convert them for use on a PSP or an iPod with video. It also lets you create Blu-ray discs if you have a Blu-ray burner attached, or LightScribe discs if you have a LightScribe drive. Unfortunately, our test system wasn't equipped to handle these abilities.