McAfee Total Protection 2010 (1 User) review: McAfee Total Protection 2010 (1 User)

One thing that's notable about McAfee's updates is that none of the lesser products have their security features hamstrung in an effort to get more people to upgrade. What's available in McAfee Total Protection, the high-end version, is nearly identical to what's in the basic consumer McAfee AntiVirus Plus. What McAfee hopes users will find worth upgrading for is Mozy Online Backup, with McAfee Internet Security users getting 1GB free and McAfee Total Protection users getting 2GB free; and parental controls. The Home Network Defense feature is only available in McAfee Total Protection. It allows you to see network settings of yours and other computers on your network, and to mark a computer on your home network as an intruder which will prevent it from accessing other computers on the network.

Several features have been discontinued from previous versions. SystemGuards has been fully replaced by Artemis, and local backup has been replaced by Mozy. The Personal Information Protection, in which a user could enter personal data such as social security numbers or credit card info and expect to have its unintended dissemination over the Internet prevented was discontinued for not being effective. The PasswordVault for securing passwords on the Web has been replaced by browser-provided password protection, and the EasyNetwork system for local file-sharing has been replaced by Windows 7's file-sharing system. This anticipates data just released, that in the few months that Windows 7 has been available to the public it has taken more than 10 percent of the operating system market share.

Performance

Boot time
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)
Standard machine
40.03 

Shutdown time
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

Scan time
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)
Standard machine
N/A

Office performance
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

iTunes decoding
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

Media multitasking test
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

Cinebench
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
Standard machine
4,217 

As with most program overhauls, McAfee promises faster install times, faster scan times, more effective scans and a small memory footprint. In empirical testing, the first fast scan finished in under 10 minutes. Because of file marking, subsequent fast scans finished in under a minute. The first full scan took nearly 85 minutes.

McAfee claims that the first full scan will be 55 minutes faster on the 2010 version as compared with the 2009 version. Subsequent full scans should be an astounding 120 minutes faster, from 135 minutes to 15 minutes. McAfee also claims that users should see their computers with the 2010 version start up 300 percent faster than with the 2009 version, and that computer shutdowns with the new version should be 30 percent faster.

The most likely reason for the massive improvement in start-up time is that, like a few other security vendors, McAfee doesn't fully load all of its processes by the time that you can start using programs on your desktop. Brian Trombley, McAfee's director of consumer product management, stated that this doesn't affect the security of the computer, only that the McAfee interface isn't full accessible until about 90 seconds after the system tray icons appear.

In benchmark tests performed by CNET Labs, McAfee's 2010 programs generally scored near or slightly above average, but not in every case. Some highlights from the charts here include noting that the high-end McAfee Total Protection 2010 slowed startup times by three seconds, while the base-level McAfee AntiVirus Plus added only 2.1 seconds. By comparison, many competitors added anywhere from 10 seconds to 19 seconds to start-up times. Across the board, two of the McAfee programs added only 1 second to shutdown times, and one added 1.1 seconds. Both those numbers are very good.

However, in full-scan times, McAfee Total Protection is so far the slowest of the 2010 security suites we've tested, taking 40 minutes to complete a scan on our test machine. Many competitors took less than half that time. McAfee also did well in our iTunes decoding test, with McAfee Total Protection taking 193 seconds, tied for the fastest program with Avast. Meanwhile, McAfee Internet Security was one of the fastest programs in the Cinebench test, tied for fourth fastest.

What this means is that as a group, McAfee's 2010 suites have a smaller-than-average impact on your computer's resources, although they tend to be slower than average at their primary scanning task.

Malware detection and blocking tests performed by independent evaluator AV-Test.org found McAfee Internet Security 2010 in the middle of its test pack. In mid-December 2009, it detected 87.2 percent of threats launched at it, with few false positives. It successfully blocked 86.7 percent of those threats. AV-Comparatives.org found the 2009 product to score Advanced+ on three tests, Advanced on three tests, and Standard on two tests. This placed McAfee in the middle of the AV-Comparatives testing group, as well.

Support
McAfee's support exists, but it's almost entirely online as forums and live chat. There are "Learn More" and "Help" links throughout the program, as well as mouse-over explanations, and McAfee offers free customer service chat and e-mail. Phone customer service is free for the first 30 days of the program license, but will cost you after that.

Support for paid products in general has been diminishing over the years, in part because of robust user forums and other self-service tools such as FAQs. However, in the highly competitive security field, with strong free options for users, customer service is one area where the paid products could do more than they have of late.

Conclusion
Overall, McAfee's 2010 products felt light and didn't interfere with heavy computer use over a half-day of real-world testing. The initial indexing scan is the key to enjoying faster scan times with the McAfee's 2010 products, and users looking for a change of pace might appreciate the new interface. While the performance benchmarks are fairly strong, and the program's usability has improved, what we've seen from third-party testers is that the benchmarks need to improve before the program can earn a rating.

Don't Miss

 

Join the discussion

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Where to Buy See all prices

McAfee Total Protection 2010 (1 User)

Part Number: MTP10EMB1RAA
MSRP: $59.99 Low Price: $7.00 See all prices

Quick Specifications See All

  • Category security applications
  • Compatibility PC
Hot Products