Lexmark X5470 review: Lexmark X5470

Performance
Compared to other multifunctions in its price range, the Lexmark X5470 performed decently in the speed tests. It was quite fast at text prints, spitting out 6.90 pages per minute. It printed 4x6 photos at 0.53ppm, behind both the Canon Pixma MP160 and the Pixma MP460, but right in line with the Brother MFC-440cn and the HP OfficeJet 4315. It made a pretty good showing with scanning too, scanning grayscale and color documents at 5.66ppm and 5.13ppm, respectively. It's Achilles' heel, though, was copying: It produced a mere 1.32ppm, compared to the Officejet 4315's 5.08ppm.

CNET Labs' multifunction printer performance
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)
Copy speed  
Color scan speed  
Grayscale scan speed  
4x6 photo speed  
Text speed  
Lexmark X5470
1.32 
5.13 
5.66 
0.53 
6.9 
Canon Pixma MP180
N/A
5.61 
6.47 
1.36 
5.81 
Canon Pixma MP460
N/A
5.6 
5.68 
1.36 
5.8 
HP OfficeJet 4315
5.08 
1.63 
1.66 
0.49 
4.14 
Brother MFC-440cn
2.76 
3.62 
4.43 
0.53 
2.81 

Unfortunately, print speed comes at a price for the X5470: quality. The text quality was disappointingly bad. Although the text was legible, it was shrouded in fuzziness, and letters were inconsistently formed, almost as if it were printed from a fax machine instead of a printer. The color graphics print showed decent color reproduction, though the entire print had a slightly faded quality to it. We noticed graininess in color blocks, especially in the photo elements, and even worse, the entire page was beset by distracting horizontal lines. In a section containing vertical, bar code-like lines, the result was a crosshatched look. The 4x6 photo was equally disappointing. The color was overly somber and dull, and nothing about the photo was vibrant. We noticed a lot of graininess and, upon very close inspection, could almost make out individual dots of cyan, yellow, and magenta. The result was a general lack of sharpness and detail.

The scans were the highlight of the X5470's quality assessment, though neither the grayscale nor the color scan was spectacular. Both showed fairly good detail and sharpness, though the dark areas of the grayscale were a bit muddy. The color scan showed decent color reproduction, but the scanner had some problems reproducing a smooth color gradient.

CNET Labs' multifunction printer quality
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
Color scan  
Grayscale scan  
Photo  
Graphics on inkjet paper  
Text on inkjet paper  
Canon Pixma MP460
Fair 
Good 
Excellent 
Excellent 
Excellent 
Canon Pixma MP180
Fair 
Fair 
Good 
Excellent 
Good 
Lexmark X5470
Good 
Good 
Poor 
Fair 
Fair 
HP OfficeJet 4315
Good 
Fair 
Fair 
Poor 
Fair 
Brother MFC-440cn
Fair 
Poor 
Fair 
Poor 
Fair 

Service and support
Lexmark backs the X5470 with a one-year warranty. Free, toll-free phone support is available on weekdays from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. and on Saturdays from noon to 6 p.m. ET for the length of the warranty. Lexmark's Web site includes a knowledge base, downloadable drivers, and a resource center to help get you started on new printing projects.

What you'll pay

Editors' Top PicksSee All

  • Brother MFC-J470DW

    Starting at: $59.99
    4 stars

    The Brother MFC-J470DW delivers cloud printing from mobile devices, business-friendly...

  • Epson XP-420

    Starting at: $25.00
    4 stars

    The Epson Expression Home XP-420 inkjet printer takes all the cloud printing and wireless...

  • Samsung Xpress M2020W

    Starting at: $61.99
    4 stars

    If you're looking for a budget laser printer, the Samsung SL-M2020W should be your first...

  • Brother HL-L2360DW

    Starting at: $90.02
    4 stars

    The Brother HL-2369DW mono laser printer gets the job done with support for multiple platforms...

 

Discuss: Lexmark X5470

Conversation powered by Livefyre