iRobot Roomba Discovery review: iRobot Roomba Discovery

  • 1

CNET Editors' Rating

3.5 stars Very good
  • Overall: 7.0
  • Design: 8.0
  • Features: 7.0
  • Performance: 6.0
Review Date:
Updated on:

The Good Picks up superficial household debris well; gets itself out of tight corners; included Virtual Walls let you define vacuuming area; returns to charging dock independently.

The Bad Works slowly; misses some spots; no attachments or stair-cleaning capability; occasionally gets stuck.

The Bottom Line This robotic vacuum cleaner uses minesweeping technology to do a slow and not entirely thorough job of cleaning floors without your assistance.

Editors' Top Picks

Review summary

I was thrilled when I heard about iRobot's new robotic vacuum cleaner, the Roomba Discovery. I'd just returned from a two-week vacation, during which my cats had apparently entered some kind of preternatural fur-shedding state and done their best to transform my apartment into a small-scale replica of the Bronx Zoo. A robot that could handle the results was exactly what I wanted. The Roomba Discovery and slightly larger Discovery SE are iRobot's second generation of robotic vacuum cleaners. The attractively designed discs, each roughly 1 foot in diameter, rise only about 3 inches off the floor so that they can slip easily under furniture and other objects that you'd have to move if you were using a regular vacuum cleaner. They each come with a docking station that attaches to a 3-hour charger, as well as a wall mount, a remote control, a supply of replacement filters, and the tools needed to clean the vacuum brushes. Also included are two Virtual Wall units, which you can set up in doorways to restrict the Discovery's activity to a particular room. Here's how my mother taught me to vacuum a room: Push the vacuum back and forth in slightly overlapping rows until you've covered the whole floor, then put an attachment on it and vacuum the furniture and any tight spots on the floor. This straightforward approach has always worked pretty well for me, but it turns out to be much too rudimentary for the artificial intelligence whizzes over at iRobot. Long before the iRobot engineers were in the vacuum cleaner business, they were making minesweepers, which explains why they equipped the Roomba line with algorithms designed for clearing battlefields.

When you start up the Discovery, either with the remote or by pressing a button on the unit, it beeps a little salutatory tune and embarks from the docking station. It cuts a seemingly random path, zigzagging across the room and bumping around in corners. The path isn't really random, though--according to iRobot, the Discovery senses information about its environment 67 times per second and adjusts its path so that it will cover the whole area before returning to base. If you set it on Clean, it will cover just one room, and then go back to the docking station to charge when it's decided that cleanliness has been achieved. To cover multiple adjoining rooms, set the Discovery on Max, and it will run until the battery dies. There's also a Spot setting that causes the device to wheel around in little circles over a three-foot-diameter area in order to handle particularly nasty patches. The Roomba Discovery is pretty good at the things it's made to do: It can navigate tight spaces without getting stuck, and although it's not one of the most powerful vacuums around, it does a good job of picking up the usual household debris--including cat-fur tumbleweeds. Whenever the unit hit a really grimy spot on my hardwood and tiled floors, its blue Dirt Detect light illuminated, and it spent enough extra time on the space to pick up all the filth. It didn't choke on the paper clips and other small items I arrayed in its path, and it obeyed the restrictions of the Virtual Wall units that I set up. I was also pleased that it didn't knock over any lightweight items or seem capable of doing any damage to objects it bumps into. As a bonus, the Discovery provided a unique interactive experience for my cats.

Too good to be true, you ask? After running the Discovery several times around my hardwood and tile floors, as well as over a small piece of carpet, I found a few significant drawbacks in its performance. The first one is speed. When I restricted its activity to an 8-by-9-foot room with a hardwood floor and a 3-by-4-foot entryway, it took about 25 minutes to complete the job. That's at least 5 times as long as it would take me to clean that space thoroughly with a regular vacuum. Of course, I was in the kitchen cooking dinner while the Discovery was slaving away, so you could also look at it as having saved me 5 minutes.

Unfortunately, the Discovery isn't completely thorough either. Despite its high-tech minesweeping algorithms, the unit missed some spots, leaving about 10 percent of the dirt. That's pretty good, but I still had to finish the job with my regular vacuum. Even if 90 percent is close enough for you, you may not want to hear the Discovery running for the length of time it takes to clean a room, even though it's relatively quiet as vacuum cleaners go.

Another drawback is that the Roomba Discovery isn't above being stymied. After all, it's a machine. During one run, it fell into a sort of holding pattern in a corner that had a wall on one side and a couple of coffee table legs on the other. It spent about 15 minutes spinning around in that space, refusing to head for the open areas on its two other sides, before calling it a day and returning to its dock. The Discovery also failed to respond to the remote on occasion, going into sleep mode instead of swiveling around as I had commanded it to do. Plus, the Discovery doesn't have any attachments, so you can't use it to clean upholstery or carpeted stairs.

If you have problems pushing a vacuum cleaner around for physical reasons or simply hate vacuuming, the Roomba Discovery might be a good investment. Don't give away your old, conventional vacuum cleaner, though--you'll need it to clean that last 10 percent.

Editors' Top Picks

 

ARTICLE DISCUSSION

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Where to Buy

iRobot Roomba Discovery

Part Number: 4210 Released: Jul. 12, 2004

Newer models available starting at $279.99

Quick Specifications

  • Release date Jul. 12, 2004
About The Author