One of the more ambitious ideas for Windows 8 was that it would work equally well across a wide variety of screen sizes. Not just the 13-inch, 15-inch, and 17-inch laptops that previous versions of Windows were mostly found on, but also 8- and 11-inch systems, with a few stragglers (12.5-inch, 14-inch) in there for good measure.
What we've found over the past year is that the tile interface in Windows 8 does indeed scale well on smaller screens, although the experience inside actual apps and programs is more varied, especially if you're using a touch screen as your main interface.
Something with a 10- or 11-inch display feels like the most natural size floor for effective use by Windows 8, and we've seen a good number of products hit that mark, either as standard clamshell laptops, standalone tablets with optional keyboards, or hybrids that straddle the line between the two.
That's why Microsoft's flagship Surface Pro 2 has a 10.6-inch screen, and why we liked the recent Asus TransformerBook T100. Dell's 8-inch tablet, the Venue 8 Pro, was fine but finicky to use, and therefore the Venue 11 Pro (it's actually an 10.8-inch screen) comes off as more impressive -- still portable, but better configured for actually getting things done.
In one sense, its a direct competitor to the Surface Pro, but with more configuration flexibility -- our review unit is the $499 Intel Atom CPU version, while both Core i3 and Core i5 versions are available for up to $849.
In everyday use, the Venue 11 Pro works as well as any comparable product, and also has a few distinct advantages, including a solidly built chassis and an add-on keyboard that makes it feel much more like a laptop than the Surface does. Most importantly, it has a default full-HD 1,920x1,080-pixel display, which is something very rarely found in a screen this size.
But your $499 initial investment covers only the tablet itself, and adding the keyboard is an astounding additional $160 (it was as a little as $140 as of last week) -- although the keyboard also has an extra built-in battery. $660 for an 11-inch Intel Atom PC sounds a bit crazy, especially as the 10-inch Asus T100 includes the keyboard (while skimping on a few other specs) for under $400. Worse, while the keyboard feels great, it lacked the responsiveness we expected.
With the Venue 11 Pro, you're paying a premium for the excellent design and the full-HD display. If you don't need 1080p, there are less-expensive alternatives out there.
|Dell Venue 8 Pro||Asus Transformer Book T100||Acer Iconia W3|
|Display size/resolution||10.8-inch, 1,920x1,800 touch screen||10.1-inch, 1,366x768 touch screen||8.1-inch, 1,280x800 touch screen|
|PC CPU||1.46GHz Intel Atom Z3770||1.3GHz Intel Atom Z3740||1.8GHz Intel Atom Z2760|
|PC Memory||2048MB DDR3 SDRAM 1,333MHz||2948MB DDR2 SDRAM 800MHz||2948MB DDR2 SDRAM 800MHz|
|Graphics||32GB Intel HD Graphics||32GB Intel HD Graphics||Intel GMA 1003MB shared|
|Storage||64GB SSD hard drive||64GB SSD hard drive||64GB SSD hard drive|
|Networking||802.11 b/g/n wireless, Bluetooth 4.0||802.11b/g/n wireless, Bluetooth 4.0||802.11 b/g/n wireless, Bluetooth 4.0|
|Operating system||Windows 8.1 (32-bit)||Windows 8 (32-bit)||Windows 8 (32-bit)|
Design and features
When in its laptop form, connected to its chunky keyboard base, the Venue 11 Pro looks and feels a lot like other recent ultraportables, and even echoes the classic netbook design that sold so many Atom-powered subnotebooks years ago. Picked up, however, the weight and balance feels off, as the top-heavy clamshell feels likely to tip over at any moment. In real-world use, the system actually stayed upright most of the time, thanks in part to a small kickstand-like lip at the intersection of keyboard and screen.
Taken apart, by a pill-like plastic button in the center of the hinge, the 11.6-inch tablet screen is substantial. Unlike some of the more plastic-feeling 10- and 11-inch Windows 8 tablets we've tested, the Venue 11 Pro could likely stand up to some rugged travel, and the soft-touch finish on the back was not especially prone to smudges or scratches. One problem with the hinge/connection is that pulling the screen away from the keyboard dock almost always caused me to accidentally press the power button, which sits along the top edge of the tablet.
As a standalone tablet, the Venue 11 Pro delivered, with good on-screen typing, an accelerometer that wasn't too sensitive. Volume controls on the side edge, along with Micro-USB and SD card slots make it reasonably easy to use this as a standalone device.
Of course, for a more all-day experience, you'll want to add a keyboard and touch pad or mouse. Dell makes it easy, with a snap-on keyboard dock that transforms the combined system into a traditional clamshell laptop. The dock also has its own internal battery, which in our testing, more than doubled battery life.
However, for about $160, on top of the base tablet price of $499, it makes the full system cost as much as a budget-minded Intel Core i-series laptop. On the positive side, the keyboard is well-built, with solid, chunky island-style keys that feel great to type on. Despite its small size, important keys such as Shift, Tab, and Enter are not short-changed
But the story is not all positive. When using the keyboard, I encountered occasional lag or missed keystrokes. The keyboard physically connects to the tablet rather than using a Bluetooth connection, so it's even more surprising, although we have run into similar issues with other hybrids in the past.
The touch pad on the keyboard dock is too small to do much more than basic on-screen navigation. And while it felt more responsive than the keyboard, two-finger scrolling on Web pages was difficult, as was selecting blocks of text. But, on a small tablet-based system such as this, one might be expected to use on-screen touch controls for much of your navigation.