Why you should think twice about buying a new BlackBerry

Research In Motion is readying a wave of new BlackBerrys for the market, but should you pick one up? CNET explains why that might be a bad idea.

commentary If you're thinking about picking up one of those fancy new BlackBerrys, let me explain for a minute or so why that may not be a very good idea.

AT&T will sell the BlackBerry Torch 9810, one of several BlackBerrys coming out in the coming weeks. AT&T

Research In Motion finally answered the pleas of the BlackBerry faithful for a new device with a promotional blitz today, announcing multiple phones for different carriers around the world. In the U.S., AT&T has committed to selling three BlackBerrys, including a next-generation Torch, the touch-screen version of its smash-hit Bold phone, and a touch-screen-only phone called the Torch 9860. Sprint Nextel said it too will be carrying the Bold and a variant of the all-touch-screen phone called the Torch 9850.

In fairness, I haven't had a chance yet to play with the new BlackBerrys. But there are serious business and technology issues that should make you think twice before you buy one of the new ones unveiled today. From an operating system destined for irrelevancy to the continued lack of worthy applications, this latest line of smartphones from RIM may be dead on arrival. If you need to change phones, and your company isn't forcing you to use a BlackBerry, you're better off moving over to the iPhone or an Android smartphone.

Sounds harsh, but I'm not the only one down on the BlackBerry. According to a survey taken by NPD Connected Intelligence, roughly a third of those asked about their next smartphone said it would be either an Android handset or iPhone. A paltry 8 percent said they were looking for a BlackBerry. It's hard to say that cost is the issue. While pricing isn't available, they will likely be priced competitively with the iPhone and other high-end smartphones.

The latest BlackBerrys run on the newest version of its operating system, BlackBerry OS 7 . While an improvement over past operating systems, in reality it represents only a minor update over OS 6, found in the original Torch that debuted a year ago. It was originally known as OS 6.1, but was renamed to 7 because the company claimed the update was so big. A more cynical person would suggest RIM was engaging in overly enthusiastic marketing to better sell its devices.

Related links
• Hands-on with BlackBerry's new OS 7 devices
• Sprint gets new Bold and Torch
• How to bridge your Playbook to a BlackBerry

Big update or not, it's not going to be around for very long. RIM said it is moving to its next-generation operating system, called QNX, next year. The software already powers the PlayBook tablet, which despite getting panned by reviewers, worked smoothly as an operating system.

If customers buy a BlackBerry now, they're left with an operating system that will be out of date halfway through their two-year contract. Nokia is dealing with the same dilemma as it manages its transition to Microsoft's Windows Phone operating system . In the meantime, the company is positioning its older Symbian platform as a mass-market smartphone phone.

the BlackBerry Torch 9850 will be sold through Sprint Nextel Sprint

There are other issues. Despite many attempts, RIM still hasn't answered the increasing demand for applications. The iPhone and Android devices can do more than the basics of phone calls and Internet browsing, and it's something that RIM continues to neglect. BlackBerry offers only a fraction of the number of applications available to iOS and Android users.

Last month, RIM said its App World had hit 1 billion application downloads , a significant milestone for the company but still behind its rivals. Apple earlier in the month said it had passed the 15 billion download mark, while Google said in May that more than 4.5 billion applications were downloaded through Android Market.

To be fair, RIM has hopefully addressed the hardware issues that have long plagued the devices, giving the new line a boost in specifications such as application processing speed and memory. RIM officials promised much of the same with the original underpowered Torch, but they appear to have delivered with the newest wave of SnapDragon-powered phones.

William Stofega, an analyst at IDC, said that the improved design of the Bold Touch will likely keep some of the BlackBerry faithful in the fold.

"It definitely fills a void in the portfolio that they didn't have with the Storm," he said.

And BlackBerry remains a good platform if all you're interested in is access to e-mail and a higher level of security. It will remain a fixture in government agencies and companies with sensitive security requirements.

But if you're looking to do more than simple e-mail and Web browsing, BlackBerry may not be your best bet.

About the author

Roger Cheng is the executive editor in charge of breaking news for CNET News. Prior to this, he was on the telecommunications beat and wrote for Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal for nearly a decade. He's a devoted Trojan alum and Los Angeles Lakers fan.

 

Join the discussion

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Show Comments Hide Comments
Latest Galleries from CNET
Nissan gives new Murano bold style (pictures)
Top great space moments in 2014 (pictures)
This is it: The Audiophiliac's top in-ear headphones of 2014 (pictures)
ZTE's wallet-friendly Grand X (pictures)
Lenovo reprises clever design for the Yoga Tablet 2 (Pictures)
Top-rated reviews of the week (pictures)