The Microsoft Surface Pro 3: Bigger is better

Microsoft made good design decisions for the Pro 3. That's important, because prior versions always seemed like interesting placeholders till a more fully realized concept came along.

surface-pro-3-hallway-small.jpg
The Surface Pro 3: Microsoft finally figured out the optimal physical design. Brooke Crothers/CNET

The Surface Pro 3 is a vast improvement over the Pro 1 and 2 -- and that alone is huge.

Microsoft nailed the physical design -- I knew that the first time I used a Pro 3 two weeks ago. And now that I have one (as of Friday), I can tell you why. What follows are my initial impressions. A longer-term evaluation will come later.

Note that I used both the Surface Pro and Surface Pro 2 extensively (one was sold, the other traded in). So, for the most part, this brief review (CNET's in-depth review is here) will contrast the Pro 3 with prior generations.

Display -- bigger is (much) better: A 12-inch display combined with a 3:2 aspect ratio makes -- at the risk of sounding redundant -- a big difference. The previous 10.6-inch Pros with their 16:9 aspect ratio made it hard to be productive. And I've come to believe that bigger tablets -- with roomier displays -- are definitely better than smaller ones. Need a small tablet? Then get a large phone or a phablet.

To wit, I prefer the larger iPad Air to the iPad Mini Retina, the larger Nexus 10 to the Nexus 7, and I would take Samsung's 12.2-inch Galaxy Tab Pro over the smaller Galaxy tablets. (And I now favor 14- and 13-inch laptops over the 11.6-inch MacBook Air, which I used for a long time.)

Bye-bye, brick analogies: Weight distribution is really important but rarely covered in reviews. The old Pro compressed 2 pounds into a chassis built around a 10.6-inch display. The Pro 3 spreads less weight (1.76 pounds) over a wider/longer but thinner 12-inch-class chassis. Gone are the brick analogies.

Bigger, better keyboard and touchpad: I'm typing now on the Pro 3's Type Cover keyboard and it comes a lot closer to the 13-inch MacBook Pro Retina's keyboard (which I also use) than the Pro 2's. This also fits into the bigger-is-better theme: with a larger chassis, you get a more spacious keyboard.

Ditto on the touchpad. It's not only larger but has mechanical feedback (it clicks). Let me be blunt, the Pro 2's seemed like a conspiracy to combine the worst aspects of a touchpad. Not only was it too small, but because Microsoft matched it perfectly with the surrounding fabric, it also vanished into the keyboard. I spent way too much time just trying to find the damn thing.

Prettier too: I've had Surface 2 envy for a while. In other words, I liked the design of the Windows RT-based Surface 2 with its metallic-looking silver backside and slimmer profile but was reluctant to buy a device that ran the unpopular RT operating system. The Pro 3 matches the Surface 2's aesthetics -- and is just as thin, runs Windows 8.1, and uses a speedy Intel Haswell processor, to boot.

MacBook Air as a yardstick: I think Microsoft should probably tone down the ad campaign that compares the Pro 3 to the MacBook Air. Too many people are wedded to their Airs for reasons that the Pro 3 cannot improve on.

I think, rather, it could be a better iPad Air (as a starting point, at least). For instance, I've decided, as an experiment, to sideline the Air then see where that takes me. I use the Air a lot for work when I'm on the road but there are certain mission-critical tasks that the Air just can't handle (and, believe me, I've tried). And this could ultimately play into the laptop replacement scenario: more time on the Pro 3 would mean less time using a MacBook.

And in this respect, Microsoft is ahead of Apple. Rumor has it that Apple is working on a 12- or 13-inch class "iPad Pro" and/or possibly a new 12-inch version of the MacBook Air. Unless Apple comes up with some mind-blowing hybrid design, Redmond is the trendsetter, not Cupertino.

In closing, let me say that though first impressions count, they're not definitive. I will do a long-term review after I've gotten to know the Pro 3's strengths and weaknesses better.

Updated at 4:10 p.m. PDT on June 22. Expands iPad Air discussion at bottom.

surface-pro-3-floor-small.jpg
It's thin! It's longer and wider but thinner and lighter. That makes a big difference. Brooke Crothers/CNET

surface-pro-3-photoshop-small.jpg
Running Adobe Photoshop with scaled interface. Lori Grunin/CNET

About the author

Brooke Crothers writes about mobile computer systems, including laptops, tablets, smartphones: how they define the computing experience and the hardware that makes them tick. He has served as an editor at large at CNET News and a contributing reporter to The New York Times' Bits and Technology sections. His interest in things small began when living in Tokyo in a very small apartment for a very long time.

 

Join the discussion

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Don't Miss
Hot Products
Trending on CNET

HOT ON CNET

Find Your Tech Type

Take our tech personality quiz and enter for a chance to win* high-tech specs!