Technology voter guide 2006 - Senate methodology
See how CNET News.com graded Senate votes ranging from e-commerce restrictions to mandated library filters.
See how CNET News.com graded Senate votes ranging from e-commerce restrictions to mandated library filters.
Staff Writers, CNET News.com
Published: November 2, 2006 4:00 AM PST
del.icio.us Digg this
A signifies a tech-friendly vote; an X means a tech-unfriendly vote.
For an overview of Senate voting scores, click here. (You'll need an installed application that can read spreadsheets such as Microsoft Excel Viewer, OpenOffice.org or Google Spreadsheets.)
1. For
the Communications Decency Act.
The U.S. Supreme Court gutted this unconstitutional measure on grounds that it
violated Americans' free-expression rights protected by the First Amendment.
June 1995
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
2. For
the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.
Section 1201 of this 1998 law imposed "anti-circumvention" restrictions on
computer science researchers and
May 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
3. Prohibiting Internet gambling.
This said that, with a few exceptions designed to benefit favored industries
such as horse racing, "it shall be unlawful for a person knowingly to use the
Internet or any other interactive computer service to place, receive, or
otherwise make a bet or wager with any person."
July 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
4. Making
it more difficult to renew the Net tax ban.
This pro-tax amendment sought to require a three-fifths supermajority in both
the House and the Senate to extend the moratorium on Internet taxation.
October 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
5. Increasing
paperwork for Internet sellers.
This amendment said anyone selling something on the Internet, including eBay
sellers, must complete additional paperwork or be fined by the federal
government. It added restrictions that did not exist for people selling items
through newspapers, garage sales or magazines.
October 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
6. For
more e-commerce restrictions.
This was a vote to table (that is, postpone discussion of) an amendment. It
would impose restrictions on the online sale of firearms, singling out the
Internet but not telephone, newspaper classified ads or in-person purchases.
May 1999
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
7. For
Internet filters in schools and libraries.
The subsequent law, narrowly upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court, said libraries
and schools receiving federal funding must filter the Internet. Adults seeking
unfiltered connections have to ask permission.
June 2000
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
8. Making
the ban on Net access taxes permanent.
In both the Senate and the House of Representatives, we gave high marks to
politicians who voted for a moratorium on Internet access taxes.
May 2001
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
9. To
liberalize computer export restrictions.
This amendment said that in specific circumstances, "a license shall not be
required for the export of after-market service or replacement parts."
September 2001
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
10. Against
taxing purchases made online.
This postpones discussion of an amendment designed to let a minority of state
governments force other states to let online and mail order purchases be taxed
(when they currently are not).
November 2001
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
11. For
free trade bill.
This bill contained Trade Promotion Authority for the president, which benefits
free trade and is backed by technology firms.
August 2002
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
12. Overruling
state antispam laws with the Can-Spam Act.
This zapped tougher state laws that in some cases gave spam victims more
rights, and it has hardly stemmed the flow of junk e-mail.
October 2003
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
13. Extending
the ban on Internet access taxes through 2007.
In both the Senate and the House of Representatives, we gave high marks to
politicians who voted for a moratorium on Internet access taxes.
April 2004
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
14. For
research and development tax credit.
Renewing this was a key concern of technology firms, with the Information
Technology Association of America
September 2004
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
15. For
nationalized ID card, linking databases.
The Real ID Act creates what amounts to a
national identity card with "common machine-readable technology." It also
raises privacy concerns by saying it will "provide electronic access by a state
to information contained in the motor vehicle databases of all other states."
May 2005
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
See how CNET News.com graded Senate votes ranging from e-commerce restrictions to mandated library filters.
Staff Writers, CNET News.com
Published: November 2, 2006 4:00 AM PST
del.icio.us Digg this
A signifies a tech-friendly vote; an X means a tech-unfriendly vote.
For an overview of Senate voting scores, click here. (You'll need an installed application that can read spreadsheets such as Microsoft Excel Viewer, OpenOffice.org or Google Spreadsheets.)
1. For
the Communications Decency Act.
The U.S. Supreme Court gutted this unconstitutional measure on grounds that it
violated Americans' free-expression rights protected by the First Amendment.
June 1995
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
2. For
the Digital Millennium Copyright Act.
Section 1201 of this 1998 law imposed "anti-circumvention" restrictions on
computer science researchers and
May 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
3. Prohibiting Internet gambling.
This said that, with a few exceptions designed to benefit favored industries
such as horse racing, "it shall be unlawful for a person knowingly to use the
Internet or any other interactive computer service to place, receive, or
otherwise make a bet or wager with any person."
July 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
4. Making
it more difficult to renew the Net tax ban.
This pro-tax amendment sought to require a three-fifths supermajority in both
the House and the Senate to extend the moratorium on Internet taxation.
October 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
5. Increasing
paperwork for Internet sellers.
This amendment said anyone selling something on the Internet, including eBay
sellers, must complete additional paperwork or be fined by the federal
government. It added restrictions that did not exist for people selling items
through newspapers, garage sales or magazines.
October 1998
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
6. For
more e-commerce restrictions.
This was a vote to table (that is, postpone discussion of) an amendment. It
would impose restrictions on the online sale of firearms, singling out the
Internet but not telephone, newspaper classified ads or in-person purchases.
May 1999
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
7. For
Internet filters in schools and libraries.
The subsequent law, narrowly upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court, said libraries
and schools receiving federal funding must filter the Internet. Adults seeking
unfiltered connections have to ask permission.
June 2000
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
8. Making
the ban on Net access taxes permanent.
In both the Senate and the House of Representatives, we gave high marks to
politicians who voted for a moratorium on Internet access taxes.
May 2001
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
9. To
liberalize computer export restrictions.
This amendment said that in specific circumstances, "a license shall not be
required for the export of after-market service or replacement parts."
September 2001
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
10. Against
taxing purchases made online.
This postpones discussion of an amendment designed to let a minority of state
governments force other states to let online and mail order purchases be taxed
(when they currently are not).
November 2001
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
11. For
free trade bill.
This bill contained Trade Promotion Authority for the president, which benefits
free trade and is backed by technology firms.
August 2002
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
12. Overruling
state antispam laws with the Can-Spam Act.
This zapped tougher state laws that in some cases gave spam victims more
rights, and it has hardly stemmed the flow of junk e-mail.
October 2003
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=
13. Extending
the ban on Internet access taxes through 2007.
In both the Senate and the House of Representatives, we gave high marks to
politicians who voted for a moratorium on Internet access taxes.
April 2004
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
14. For
research and development tax credit.
Renewing this was a key concern of technology firms, with the Information
Technology Association of America
September 2004
How we scored it: Yes=, No=X
15. For
nationalized ID card, linking databases.
The Real ID Act creates what amounts to a
national identity card with "common machine-readable technology." It also
raises privacy concerns by saying it will "provide electronic access by a state
to information contained in the motor vehicle databases of all other states."
May 2005
How we scored it: Yes=X, No=