X

In Apple v. Samsung, the jury has spoken

<b>week in review</b> Jury verdict favors Apple overwhelmingly in a landmark patent decision. Also: Facebook rolls out new features, and an exclusive peek at tech's most hated company.

Michelle Meyers
Michelle Meyers wrote and edited CNET News stories from 2005 to 2020 and is now a contributor to CNET.
Michelle Meyers
5 min read
James Martin/CNET

Apple and Samsung both rested their cases this week in the ongoing billion-dollar patent infringement dispute, and the jury has found Apple the clear victor.

After 21 hours of deliberation, a nine-person jury Friday afternoonsided with Apple on a majority of its patent infringement claims against Samsung Electronics. The jury also awarded Apple more than $1 billion in damages.

Apple had originally sought $2.75 billion in damages and although it wasn't unanimous on all counts, the verdict was overwhelmingly in Apple's favor.
•  Apple's $1,049,343,540 victory: Google, don't tread on me
•  Apple's big win over Samsung -- what does it mean?

Apple's closing arguments had focused on the documents at the heart of its courtroom offensive. The company's attorney highlighted a series of internal Samsung documents, many of which showed that Samsung looked to Apple's devices for cues when designing its software icons and general features.

Samsung closed its case by painting Apple as a company that is stifling market competition not just in the U.S. but in the tech world at large. And it argued that any product design similarities are not copying, but benchmarking -- the practice in which companies keep up with rivals on things like screen size, battery life, and other core features.

The option to appeal could drag this case on for several more years. A separate appeals case between the two regarding software elements of Android and a potential ban on the Galaxy Nexus is set to start in 2014.

Further complicating matters is this week's decision from a South Korean courtthat both companies infringed on each others' patents, resulting in bans and fines on both sides. The two have sued each other in multiple courts in multiple countries, potentially extending the entanglements for years.

So while a verdict might not have much of a near-term impact,the potential ramifications are huge.
•  Full coverage: Apple v. Samsung
•  Apple v. Samsung: Why is Judge Koh so angry?
•  Apple-Samsung jury: Verdict form may blow your minds
•  The ABCs of Apple v. Samsung

Tech smackdowns: 9 court confrontations that mattered (pictures)

See all photos

More headlines

Bigger ads, bigger bucks? Facebook feels Wall Street heat

With Facebook's stock now half of its IPO price, Mark Zuckerberg and company are testing more ways to make money from advertising. And they can do a lot more.
•  Facebook cleared to acquire Instagram
•  Facebook messages start looking more like e-mail
•  Facebook's search results now include ads
•  Review: Facebook is much faster with a new photo UI

Facebook's interface makes it easy to stay connected (pictures)

See all photos

Inside Intellectual Ventures, the most hated company in tech

Nathan Myhrvold and other executives at the controversial company say critics simply don't understand what they're doing. CNET went behind the scenes to understand what 40,000 patents and an unapologetic plan to make money from them really means.
•  Remember invisibility cloak tech? It's useful for talking to satellites

Inside Intellectual Ventures' patent factory (pictures)

See all photos

Tim Cook breezes through first year in post-Jobs era

It's now been a year at the helm for Apple's top executive, who is under more scrutiny than just about any corporate honcho anywhere.
•  10 key moments during Tim Cook's first year as CEO (pictures)

Curiosity takes a spin on Mars, completes short test drive

NASA's $2.5 billion rover takes a short spin on Mars, proving that the mobile science lab is, in fact, mobile -- and ready to begin roaming about Gale Crater to look for signs of past or present habitability.
•  Curiosity lands on Mars again, this time in HD
•  Curiosity flight director's family lives on 'Mars time'
•  NASA plans mission to study hidden interior of Mars

Curiosity's ChemCam laser zaps its first target on Mars (pictures)

See all photos

More evidence suggests Sept. 21 iPhone release

A report from TechCrunch indicates that Verizon has set an employee vacation blackout from September 21 to 30.
•  Could the iPhone 5 be... ahem, a camera?
•  Leaked iPhone parts assembled, fit 'perfectly'
•  Images of alleged iPhone 5 logic board, USB cable surface
•  Video shows purported iPhone 5 internals, front plate
•  Alleged iPhone prototype surfaces -- and check out that logo

Microsoft squares off with new logo

Out with the old, in with the new -- logo, that is. As Redmond gets ready to unleash Windows 8 and a wave of other new products, it does a little design housekeeping.
•  Microsoft's new logo: This took 25 years?
•  Microsoft logos through the years (pictures)
•  Yes, a Microsoft Store wows a naysayer

Rare peek: Inside Symantec's security fortress

The security world doesn't trust the Web. Symantec wants to prove naysayers wrong.

Inside Symantec's secret SSL Certificate Vault (pictures)

See all photos

AT&T defends FaceTime restrictions amid sharp criticism

Consumer advocates have accused AT&T of violating FCC rules by requiring Apple FaceTime users to subscribe to the carrier's Mobile Share plans. In a blog post, AT&T defends its position.
•  AT&T's FaceTime limits might conflict with FCC rules
•  Verizon wins FCC approval for spectrum deals -- with caveats

Amazon set to introduce new Kindles at September 6 event

Amazon has sent out invites for a press conference in Santa Monica, Calif., where it's expected the company will introduce new Kindle devices
•  Nintendo to hold Wii U event in NYC on September 13

Hewlett-Packard sucks wind with $8.9B loss, cuts outlook

HP's third-quarter results are, well, not good. The company is "still in the early stages of a multiyear turnaround," CEO Meg Whitman says.
•  HP faces iPad entrenchment at businesses, say observers
•  Dell profit and revenues shrink, and so does its outlook

Best Buy chooses turnaround specialist as new CEO

Hubert Joly, former CEO of hospitality giant Carlson, has been named to lead the struggling electronics retailer.
•  Best Buy shows strains in second-quarter earnings

T-Mobile cuts the strings on new data plan, goes fully unlimited

The carrier is following in the path of Sprint Nextel and targeting heavy data users with no caps or throttling.
•  Who has the better unlimited plan? Sprint vs. T-Mobile
•  MetroPCS unveils $55 unlimited 4G plan and new 4G phone

Also of note
•  Hey Google, share that Nexus love beyond Samsung
•  PayPal brings digital wallet to merchants through Discover
•  My cyborg sister: When life-saving gadgets break down
•  Surveillance device uses Wi-Fi to see through walls
•  Google: Time to ditch our current software patent system?
•  New radar tech helps pilots nimbly avoid severe weather

Updated at 5:04 p.m. PT with the jury's verdict.