Google TV or a Nettop?

How does a Google TV-based device like the Logitech Revue compare with a similarly priced Windows 7 Nettop?

The Logitech Revue unveiling earlier this week provided details about yet another device in the $99 to $399 price range competing to bring Web-based video content to your television. Alongside the Google TV-based Revue, we also have boxes from Apple, Roku, as well as the forthcoming D-Link Boxee Box. We would also add the Xbox 360, the PlayStation 3, and Web-enabled Blu-ray players to that mix and, in addition to those specialized devices, Nettop PCs.

The Logitech Revue adds a number of fundamental improvements to the streaming video device category.
The Logitech Revue. Logitech

If a Nettop represents the most open option for its configurability and its access to the unfettered Web, and a PlayStation 3 offers the most powerful hardware with its Blu-ray drive and gaming capabilities, the Revue falls somewhere in the middle. Like many Nettops, it has no optical drive. Like the PlayStation 3, the Revue lacks the greater software and peripheral device flexibility of a traditional Windows-based computer.

Perhaps the Revue's biggest selling point is its broad range of content. Logitech and Google have announced support for Amazon VOD, NetFlix, Pandora and YouTube, as well as programming from TBS, TNT, CNN, and HBO. Because the Revue also includes a Google Chrome Web browser with HTML5 and Flash 10.1 plug-in support, you can also navigate to any Web-based content that supports those standards, at least provided it's not explicitly blocked, as with Hulu. On top of all of that, the Revue will support application downloads from the Android Marketplace in 2011. We would also be remiss if we failed to note the various existing Android BitTorrent apps.

For Nettops, in spite of all their openness, we've never found a model we loved. We fail to understand why a $299 or even a $399 computer should have lesser hardware than a $199 or $299 gaming console. You also have to factor in the additional cost of a proper input device for the living room. Most Nettops come with either no input devices or standard wired mice and keyboards. eMachines' recent $300 or so ER1402-05 comes with a decent wireless mouse and keyboard set, but that's an exception. That eMachines system also has difficulty playing even the generally low bit rate HD content from the Web.

Nettops like this eMachines aren't perfect, but they have their fans.
Nettops like this eMachines still have their fans. eMachines

We can't claim any hands-on experience with a Logitech Revue, but Logitech says it can play 1080p video. Like the Boxee Box, one of the Revue's core features is providing a simple search interface to look for video across all of its supported services. We haven't seen a tool for the PC that offers the same service-spanning search capability.

Potentially separating Logitech's device from its dedicated device competition, the Revue also can search for content stored on your DVR. Right now, the Revue only interacts with Dish Network DVRs. We'll see if reality meets Logitech's expectation that it will secure DVR searching for other providers. If it can, that would give the Revue the lead in content searching breadth. Throw in its internal IR blaster that can talk to your other home entertainment devices, and the Revue can also claim a large ease-of-use advantage over Nettops.

Despite the Revue's on-paper appeal, we suspect that enthusiasts will continue to prefer Nettops for their pure PC openness (LifeHacker has one example). The $299 price tag for the Revue also bears questioning, since, like Nettops, its lack of a Blu-ray drive or gaming capability looks spare next to the hardware value of a $299 PlayStation 3. We'll reserve final judgment of the Revue until we get our hands on one. For now it seems like an impressive step forward for the streaming device category. Agree? Disagree? Let us know.

Read the full CNET Review

eMachines ER1402-05

The Bottom Line: eMachines ER1402-05 is a strong living-room Nettop among others like it, but it doesn't compete well in the larger picture of living-room entertainment devices like game consoles, media streamers, and video service-equipped Blu-ray players. It's worth a look if you need a desktop of this particular type, but keep shopping if you need a connected living-room media device. / Read full review

Read the full CNET Review

Logitech Revue (Google TV)

The Bottom Line: The Logitech Revue with Google TV is loaded with potentially game-changing functionality, but its high price, numerous caveats, and current assortment of bugs make it best-suited to early adopters--at least until promised firmware fixes become available. / Read full review

About the author

Rich Brown is an executive editor for CNET Reviews. He has worked as a technology journalist since 1994.

 

ARTICLE DISCUSSION

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Don't Miss
Hot Products
Trending on CNET

Hot on CNET

CNET's giving away a 3D printer

Enter for a chance to win* the Makerbot Replicator 3D Printer and all the supplies you need to get started.