FAT32 copy bug in 10.6 Snow Leopard

Snow Leopard seems to have a bug in the Finder where copying between FAT32 partitions may result in a "file exists" error.

There is a known problem with Snow Leopard's handling of FAT32 drive partitions, where the system will run into an error when folders containing files are copied from one drive to another. This only happens when copying between FAT32 drives, and not when different filesystem types are used.

This error will pop up when copying populated folders from one FAT32 drive to another one.

This problem seems to be a bug with the Finder in Snow Leopard, and hopefully will be addressed by Apple soon; however, by the latest 10.6.2 update the bug is still present. It happens regardless of the partition scheme being used (GUID, APM, or MBR) which indicates it has to do with the filesystem driver or some handling of filenames by the process doing the copying as opposed to some conflict with the drive structure.

Specifically, the problem seems to happen only when folders containing files are copied between two FAT32 filesystems. Individual files copy just fine (even in batches), and likewise for empty folders; however, if the folder has items in it the copy error referencing the folder being copied will display.


  1. Use another filesystem format.

    If possible, use a Mac filesystem such as "Mac OS Extended" for your external drives. If you need to use a drive with a Windows machine, you have two options. The first is to install Mac filesystem support (ie, MacDrive) on your Windows machine so it can read and write Mac OS Extended partitions. The second is to install NTFS support on your Mac via MacFUSE or the NTFS component of MacFUSE (NTFS-3G).

  2. Use an intermediate drive.

    Since this problem has to do with direct FAT32-to-FAT32 copying, using an intermediate drive of a different format should allow you to successfully copy the files. If you have space you can use your boot drive, or even your Time Machine drive for this.

  3. Use alternate copying programs.

    This problem is with how the Finder handles the copying process between FAT32 filesystems, but does not seem to be present in other programs with file copying capability. Therefore, you can use the "cp", "mv", or similar Terminal commands to perform the copy process. Additionally, PathFinder and other Finder alternatives seem to work for affected people.

Questions? Comments? Post them below or email us!
Be sure to check us out on Twitter and the CNET Mac forums.

Featured Video
This content is rated TV-MA, and is for viewers 18 years or older. Are you of age?
Sorry, you are not old enough to view this content.

Details about Apple's 'spaceship' campus from the drone pilot who flies over it

MyithZ has one of the most popular aerial photography channels on YouTube. With the exception of revealing his identity, he is an open book as he shares with CNET's Brian Tong the drone hardware he uses to capture flyover shots of the construction of Apple's new campus, which looks remarkably like an alien craft.

by Brian Tong