Apple is sending some seriously mixed messages to developers this week.
In Monday's WWDC keynote, Steve Jobs made an three reasons apps are rejected (they don't do what the developer says they do, they use private APIs, or they crash).to the home crowd of Apple developers, assuring them, just as he did in his recent All Things D interview, that "95 percent of all apps submitted are accepted within seven days." He tried to reassure them that there are really only
He reiterated his commitment to two platforms--the "fully open" HTML5 standard and the "curated" App Store. And he trumpeted the fact that the company's app store revenue sharing has paid out $1 billion to developers. Plus, he said the iAds platform would be such a boon to developers that they could simply tell Apple where to put the ads and "start making money."
And then, just a few hours later, one of the paid iPad apps Jobs trumpeted on stage--the Pulse news aggregator--had been unceremoniously yanked from the App Store.
Later Tuesday, the app mysteriously reappeared, and even the developers said they didn't know why, considering they'd received a pretty pointed letter from Apple about it being removed, and instructing them, essentially, to work it out with the Times.
Now, of course, other paid readerapps exist, and, like Pulse, can presumably pull public RSS feeds from the New York Times or any Times Co. paper in just the same way and are still available in the App Store. Are they next? (I hope I didn't just ruin it for them.)
The other question that comes up, of course, is that if there are three reasons an app can be initially rejected from the store, there seem to be innumerable and incomprehensible reasons an app can be yanked from the store. Plus, the three reasons Jobs gave don't seem to include ridiculing public figures (or otherwise including objectionable content), , or any of the other reasons on this list, or, better yet, this site.
And let's not forget that, while on stage with Kara Swisher and Walt Mossberg at All Things D last week, Jobs essentially painted most of the people complaining about App Store rejections (or Mark Fiore, specifically, depending on how you read it) as "son of a bitch liar(s)." So, I guess it's not helping to complain to AppRejections.com. You're clearly just lying to get your 15 minutes of fame, you pesky would-be iPhone developer, you.
Jobs' message to developers this week might have sounded simple on stage: three easy rules to follow, 95 percent approval rate, and cash money just rolling into your pockets. Frankly, I can't believe any developer still believes any of those lines, and after the events of this week, everyone ought to be reading between them. You may think the App Store is a gold mine, but it sounds like one hell of a dangerous mine.