Apple accuses Proview of 'misleading' courts over iPad

It says China-based Proview routed the iPad name deal through a Taiwan subsidiary to raise questions over the trademark's ownership.


In its most detailed statement yet regarding its battle over the ownership of the iPad trademark in China, Apple said Proview International was deliberately "misleading" Chinese courts.

Proview tricked Apple into signing a carefully crafted agreement in 2009 that has raised questions over the trademark's rightful owner in China, Apple spokeswoman Carolyn Wu said in a statement cited by The Wall Street Journal. She went on to say that the troubled company was trying to exploit that situation to extract more money from Apple.

"Proview clearly made that arrangement so they wouldn't have to give the money to their creditors" in mainland China, Wu said. "Because they still owe a lot of people a lot of money, they are now unfairly trying to get more from Apple for a trademark we already paid for."

An attorney for the Hong Kong-based company, meanwhile, told the newspaper that Apple was "misleading the public."

"The fact is that Apple's former lawyer made a silly mistake," Xiao Caiyuan said, apparently referring to the 2009 deal Apple made with a Taiwan subsidiary of Proview even though the trademark technically belonged to the mainland-based Proview Technology Shenzhen, which is reportedly $400 million in debt.

Proview has claimed that its subsidiary didn't have the authority to sell the trademark and has reportedly been looking to settle out of court over the issue. Proview has filed numerous lawsuits in China, as well as one in the United States, that seek to keep Apple's tablet off retailer shelves and stop Apple from using the iPad trademark on its products.

But while Proview has been battling Apple over the trademark, it's also been fighting to stay in business. Taiwan-based Fubon Insurance, looking to recoup millions in outstanding debt, has filed an application to declare Proview bankrupt and have its assets liquidated.

Featured Video
This content is rated TV-MA, and is for viewers 18 years or older. Are you of age?
Sorry, you are not old enough to view this content.

Microsoft leaves Apple in the dust with tablet and laptop innovation in 2015

Will there be one Apple Ring to rule them all? That's what a patent application says. Plus, building the thinnest gadget isn't innovation anymore and Apple just got a reality check from Microsoft.

by Brian Tong