AOL nixes serial killer site
Facing threats of a national boycott, America Online takes down a member's Web site that focused on serial killers, saying the site is offensive and violates its terms of service.
Wyoming governor Jim Geringer, who came across the page while searching for documents about a serial killer he is seeking to extradite, yesterday held a joint press conference with Marc Klaas, father of slain 12-year-old Polly Klaas and founder of the Klaas Foundation for Children, and called for a boycott of AOL for hosting the Web site.
Perhaps ironically, the ACLU agreed that AOL has the right to choose the content it allows on its member pages--as long as the person putting up that content has an alternative, according to Ann Beeson, staff attorney for the ACLU.
"I get calls from people, unfortunately, all the time, who complain about AOL's practice of either taking down their Web sites or banning particular [speech]," she said. "They have a long-standing practice of controlling content on their system."
But, she added, "the bottom line is this is just another really bad policy decision of AOL, but there is not a civil-liberties issue involved because they're a private company and these people can pick another site."
If AOL had a larger part of the market, then constitutional issues would be raised, Beeson said. Right now, there probably is another place where London can post her site.
Earlier this week, after being contacted by Geringer's office, AOL had asked its Webmaster to remove a portion of the site that was particularly offensive: a serial killer start-up kit, according to AOL spokeswoman Tricia Primrose.
The company then continued to evaluate the site and decided yesterday to take the whole thing down. "[Yesterday], we made the determination that the content of this site was offensive and objectionable and not something that we wished to be associated with," she said. "The site was in violation of our terms of service."
This isn't the first time AOL has removed a site. But that doesn't mean that in every case the online service determines a site to be "objectionable."
Other have asked for sites to be removed, and AOL has turned them down. In this case, Primrose said that it would have responded the way it did had users complained about this particular site. The fact that a governor and high-profile victims'-rights activist complained did not influence AOL's decision, she noted.
This is from a member's page on America Online featuring serial killers, which the online service will be taking down. Pictured here is convicted serial killer Dan Rolling. |