Sorry but this is just my impression and it's "Not bad."
If it was mine I'd be tempted to tweak things a little. Such as that box with the Twitter, Facebook icon in it. I'd be looking for some balance of the empty space in that box to get the icons to "sit well" and look like they were not slapped into place.
But it's a nice page and if it's working well I'd just get out the tools to do some fine tuning.
I'd like to convince my boss that we need a new website - we had it done over 5 years ago. She thinks it would cost too much to have a new one - but with all the new templates and WordPress, I think we could have a new one for a reasonable price.
I'd like your feedback please - could you take a look at www.artsnw.org (Arts Northwest) and give me your opinion of the design?