10 total posts
Given the headaches of HDD video playback.
You can find too many complaints about the video decoding in Smart TVs. I'd ignore that and go with...
1. Warranty (who gives you 2 or more years?)
2. Best PQ.
Sony has got looks, Samsung's got features
Both of them are providing an year warranty. Plus, an option to extend it for 3 years.
The price is almost similar. What about the smart TV functionality of both the brands - Samsung and Sony?
No ok with PIA
I am not at all ok with Samsung PIA, but i am not worried about it.
I've been told that Sony doesn't play a lot of movie formats. I would want to watch movies with my whole family (in MKV) format. So i guess i need to test both the Televisions at the store (it is embarrassing though).
Another thing, Sony has got a 5W speaker.. A lot of people are complaining about the sound. Samsung, on the other hand, has got a 10W speaker. Is there a lot of difference between the two?
And since MKV is a container of formats.
Sorry but I'm always interested to read what folk think about video containers, encoding and the issues around this area. No maker should declare they support all MKV files since what's in a MKV can be encoded in many different ways. As the TVs are not open to tinkering yet, some folk dive into this area and come back either upset or worse for wear.
Let me be brutally honest
The idea of these HDTVs supporting even a reasonable amount of very typical file types/codecs is a pipe dream. Don't even get into something as tricky as an MKV wrapper. That's why folks often buy relatively inexpensive video streamers (a la Roku, WDTV Live, Apple TV, etc.) to do the job properly. Heck, it's easy enough to grab a bare bones laptop or old desktop and feed practically any content you like to the HDTV using free software such as VLC. That way you can control software/hardware w/o silly limitations of HDTVs.
As far as built in speakers go, it's the same song and dance. You utilize external speakers to improve any sound quality that doesn't meet your needs. Understand, one guy/family might find one HDTV suitable but the next hate it altogether. It might not be as simple as 10W > 5W either. This is why you do need to test them out properly, even though its' a pain. I would save yourself the trouble and hook it up to a simple HTIB system, or craigslist hifi for $30-50. Makes a huge difference IMNSHO, since you can dramatically increase the sound field when you can (phyiscally) separate even a cheap set of external speakers vs what Sony deems acceptable w/ 5W (etc.)
Tested both of them, Sony is better..
After 4th consecutive days of testing the televisions (even LG and Philips included), I am very confused about which one to buy.
Thank you everyone here for helping me out even with some of my silliest queries.
If you had to purchase one, which one would you have bought - Sony or Samsung? (I've posted the links above)
Why are you still confused?
Be verbose and we can help you narrow it down. We can also help you navigate towards a media streaming solution too, if the HDTV you end up with doesnt' do everything you need it to do.
IMNSHO, you have done a great job if you have at least discovered which you you prefer based on PQ.
Although I have not seen the tv in person, but...
I get the feeling maybe the Sony may have a slight edge in PQ so I tend to lean towards the Sony. As for sound and media playing features, that can be improve externally if need be in the future when you want to but PQ is what you see now is what you get. just my thought on this.