It wasn't until we tried things out with a souped-up Alienware that we netted acceptable results, though the editing software still lagged at an almost unusable pace.
As if the editing software slowdown wasn't enough of a hindrance, we were disappointed at its ease of use. One would think that having a decade of experience with nonlinear editing on Final Cut would have prepared us for the Roxio software, but unfortunately it isn't laid out nearly as logically as we would have preferred. Of course, we're not expecting game capture software to be as comprehensive as Apple's flagship editor, but Roxio's software could be very powerful if presented in a better fashion. We offered the interface up to a complete novice in our offices who reported the same shared frustrations.
For instance, selecting items on the timeline doesn't allow the user to move it forward or backward in time. The storyboard mode makes editing within a clip nearly impossible, and inserting text overlays is nowhere near intuitive as it needs to be. Overall, we'd recommend against using the included software. Instead, bring the raw capture file into something like Windows Movie Maker instead.
Users can upload their video creations directly to YouTube or Facebook from within the Roxio software, but any capable PC users will have no issues taking the few extra steps to do it manually. In that regard, the Roxio software does offer an impressive amount of output configurations.
We also can't help but notice that the Game Capture's pass-through output offers a shoddy signal when being fed into a TV. We immediately saw a good amount of ghosting on all text and plenty of blurry edges with the Game Capture connected.
Roxio's attempt to streamline the video game capture process is ultimately imperfect, but for just raw video, it works good enough--albeit with a bad output signal. We'll have to recommend against it for the gamer who plans on capturing tons of footage, aside from the gamer who may just want to record a session sporadically.
Priced at $100, there is a decent value here with the hardware/software combo, but do-it-yourselfers and marginally savvy gamers can accomplish similar feats by purchasing a cheaper component video-capturing device and using simple built-in movie-editing software.